Hypothetical question..

[kevtherev]

IF we were to get promotion this season and as I suspect Wigan,Wolves and Q.P.R get relegated. Who would you like to see us try to raid from them clubs. For me, Kevin Doyle, Luke Young, Paddy Kenny, Hugo Rodallega and one for luck Joey Barton.

 

[Ninja Elephant]

They're getting relegated because they aren't good enough for that standard of football. Maybe we shouldn't be in such a rush to pick up their players? Just a thought.

James McArthur and James McCarthy of Wigan are both very good, if a bit confusing. There are a couple of gems in there, but nothing too special. Rodallega is the most overrated player in the Premier League. Or, was. People have realised he's actually got nothing about him now I think.

 

[kevtherev]

They're getting relegated because they aren't good enough for that standard of football. Maybe we shouldn't be in such a rush to pick up their players? Just a thought.

James McArthur and James McCarthy of Wigan are both very good, if a bit confusing. There are a couple of gems in there, but nothing too special. Rodallega is the most overrated player in the Premier League. Or, was. People have realised he's actually got nothing about him now I think.

Teams get relegated because they are not collectivley good enough as a team, not individually.

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Teams get relegated because they are not collectivley good enough as a team, not individually.

Alright then, let's snap us Gary Caldwell from Wigan.

 

[BensGrandad]

From Wolves Wayne Henderson Jamie O Hara and Kevin Doyle from Wigan Victor Moses & Hugo Rodallega and QPR Nedhum Onuhua Frederico Macheda oh and possibly a certain Bobby Zamora. I must say I have put 2 or 3 from each and would at the best hope to get a couple. Wouldn't realistically expect to get any but we can dream.

 

[stss30]

Can we stop with all these threads? I appreciate it's a hypothetical question but we're still a long, long way off getting promoted. Firstly we have to make the play offs which will be very tough looking at our next four games and then even if we do that we have a 1 in 4 chance of winning them

 

[16bha]

From Wolves Wayne Henderson Jamie O Hara and Kevin Doyle QPR from Wigan Victor Moses & Hugo Rodallega and QPR Nedhum Onuhua Frederico Macheda oh and possibly a certain Bobby Zamora. I must say I have put 2 or 3 from each and would at the best hope to get a couple.

haven't thought about Zamora. Defo one to sign, but after Mickey Adams, I'm not too sure of whether a return would always be a success. Would certainly open the door for a return though. He played a massive part in our journey.

 

[BensGrandad]

Can we stop with all these threads? I appreciate it's a hypothetical question but we're still a long, long way off getting promoted. Firstly we have to make the play offs which will be very tough looking at our next four games and then even if we do that we have a 1 in 4 chance of winning them

Do you never dream if I won the lottery

 

[Racek]

Anyone think there should be a limit on threads started in one day or week?

 

[stss30]

Do you never dream if I won the lottery

I've got to be honest, if we do get promoted I won't be 'dreaming' of buying players from Wolves, Wigan and QPR.

 

[kevtherev]

Can we stop with all these threads? I appreciate it's a hypothetical question but we're still a long, long way off getting promoted. Firstly we have to make the play offs which will be very tough looking at our next four games and then even if we do that we have a 1 in 4 chance of winning them

It's not hypothetical that those three are going down. I think Blackburn have enough about them and the Muamba factor will see Bolton through.

 

[seagullondon]

Do you never dream if I won the lottery

I can safely say I have never dreamed about you winning the lottery

 

[ferring seagull]

'HYPOTHETICAL'

Well I suppose that what we should think about this is, players currently with clubs possibly exiting the premiershi- may well be on salaries with which BHA could not / would not wish to replicate. Let's not forget the parachute payments which would be a factor in players wanting ( or otherwise ) particularly to 'drop' a division.

There have been threads on here on the subject of whether or not we should go for promotion, there is no way we should not GO for it if it stared us in the face, because if we didn't, we will be facing a further three clubs next year with that advantage over us (like WHU).

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Wayne Henderson.........Hugo Rodallega

Their goalkeeper isn't so bad as to be called Wayne Henderson, that is extremely unkind, BG.

As for Rodallega. Seriously. He can't get in their team, he is a donkey. He has proven it over the last few years week in, week out. Poor footballer. He is out of contract in the summer and hopefully he goes off to join some club in the Far East so he'll never be heard of again. Incredibly overrated. He hasn't ever done anything at Wigan, a team who have never scored enough goals.

 

[8ace]

Paddy Kenny is utter toliet.

 

[kevtherev]

Their goalkeeper isn't so bad as to be called Wayne Henderson, that is extremely unkind, BG.

As for Rodallega. Seriously. He can't get in their team, he is a donkey. He has proven it over the last few years week in, week out. Poor footballer. He is out of contract in the summer and hopefully he goes off to join some club in the Far East so he'll never be heard of again. Incredibly overrated. He hasn't ever done anything at Wigan, a team who have never scored enough goals.

Rodallega is injured atm. 90 goals in 280 apps at the top level in respective country's....That's really shite.....Never done anything at Wigan, I think you will find he is there all time record goalscorer in the prem with 26. Ok that does not sound a lot, but this is Wigan we are talking about not Man Utd.

 

[magoo]

Joey Barton comes anywhere near this club, i'm off!

 

[Ninja Elephant]

Rodallega is injured atm.

Which is why they're having an upturn in form. The man is useless.

 

[Foolg]

Djibril Cisse, can never have too much flair. Oh and Sylvain Ebanks-Blake, so he can play alongside CMS in a double barreled top two.

 

[kevtherev]

Which is why they're having an upturn in form. The man is useless.

An up turn in form lol....Beating an out of sorts Liverpool team, who have drawn god knows how many games at home, does not represent an up turn in form. It represents them pulling off the shock of the day, as happens sometimes...Blackburn at Man Utd, Hull at Arsenal, the list is endless..Means nothing, they are going down.