How on Gods earth did Hope surive again tonight

[Uncle Spielberg]

Brenda V Hope, Hope were woeful and are rubbish, they can't sing, hell their not even that good looking, ok I may consider the 17 year old blonde but only if she begged me, Sharon for some reason decided to vote Hope through. The standard was pitiful again apart form Rhydian who embarrassed the competition frankly, throw the towel in the contest is over, The final wille be Rhydian V Same Difference.

Rhydian is not a pop star but after a woeful X Factor this year Rhydian may just save their blushes as he can be considered a find and a talent but he will end up starring in a West End stage show.

 

[clippedgull]

No one will ever surpass the talent of Leona Lewis. FACT.

 

[Scotty Mac]

its because they are a cowell group and phoebe carried thems

rhydian might be a breath of fresh air - a bit of classical in the chart. i actually prefer him to any of the previous winners

 

[Tom Hark Preston Park]

Who on God's earth is Hope?

 

[Robot Chicken]

Sharon wanted it to go to the public vote.

Whether the judges already knew the results of the public vote at the time is debatable.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

Leona is the best talent unearthed, although Girl's Aloud are pretty major league players, Rhydian is a real talent however so I suppose the last 4 months and 100000 auditions can just about be justified when he wins.

 

[ben andrews' girlfriend]

I have NO idea. Even though Girls aloud are (shockingly) still popular - it doesnt mean that girl bands are good anymore! In Hope, there is one girl with talent - but still is no-where near good enough.

Beverley was awesome - she had a brilliant voice, and such prescence and humility. I thought she was so good, and I cannot understand why she lost against Hope.

 

[Scotty Mac]

Leona is the best talent unearthed, although Girl's Aloud are pretty major league players, Rhydian is a real talent however so I suppose the last 4 months and 100000 auditions can just about be justified when he wins.

they will all be outshone if rhydian wins and fullfils his potential

 

[ben andrews' girlfriend]

they will all be outshone if rhydian wins and fullfils his potential

I still think Leona outshines them, but Rydian would be second. I can imagine him going more into stage stuff more than chart stuff - he would make a BRILLIANT Phantom.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

I have NO idea. Even though Girls aloud are (shockingly) still popular - it doesnt mean that girl bands are good anymore! In Hope, there is one girl with talent - but still is no-where near good enough.

Beverley was awesome - she had a brilliant voice, and such prescence and humility. I thought she was so good, and I cannot understand why she lost against Hope.

I hate to say it but it stinks of a racist vote, it happened in the USA as well when Jennifer Hudson was booted out, I wish it were not true to it is a factor I am afraid.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

I did say last week Rhydian will be the new Phantom of the Opera.

 

[ben andrews' girlfriend]

I hate to say it but it stinks of a racist vote, it happened in the USA as well when Jennifer Hudson was booted out, I wish it were not true to it is a factor I am afraid.

I dont think you can play the race card - thats a tad stupid. Leona was hardly Arian was she?

 

[clippedgull]

I hate to say it but it stinks of a racist vote, it happened in the USA as well when Jennifer Hudson was booted out, I wish it were not true to it is a factor I am afraid.

Do you mean the competition in general?

Because Leona is far from being lily white

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

its a point but race can and does come into these votes, there is no reason why Beverley would be in the bottom 2 , I may be wrong though

 

[ben andrews' girlfriend]

its a point but race can and does come into these votes, there is no reason why Beverley would be in the bottom 2 , I may be wrong though

Sharon said on the Xtra factor about the audience. As Beverley came on first, she would have missed the Strictly come dancing crowd that I think is her target audience - and would vote for her.

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

5th - Hope
4th - Leon
3rd - Nicki
2nd - Same Difference





















1st - Rhydian

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

I am still kicking myself for missing 20/1 on Rhydian at the start.

 

[clippedgull]

First: Nicki

Second: Rhydian

 

[Scotty Mac]

I still think Leona outshines them, but Rydian would be second. I can imagine him going more into stage stuff more than chart stuff - he would make a BRILLIANT Phantom.

leona is just being remarketed as another pop act doing emotional music - theres loads of them out there

rhydian has a REAL chance to offer something new. how many other classical singers are there in the charts who can adapt and do popular music as he has shown he can - possibly only charlotte church. and even if doesnt appeal to the mainstream at first, the x factor vote could be enough to get him established

 

[Uncle Spielberg]

are you mad