Surely having Howard Wilkinson on a panel selecting the England manager is the underlying issue here?
When was the last time he managed?
Let's get David Pleat to help him shall we?
We are so out of touch in this country.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Gareth Southgate - The only candidate being interviewed. Stroll on!
- Thread starter mune ni kamome
- Start date
Surely having Howard Wilkinson on a panel selecting the England manager is the underlying issue here?
When was the last time he managed?
Let's get David Pleat to help him shall we?
We are so out of touch in this country.
It's not a particularly big talent pool that the FA are picking from.
1066familyman
Radio User
- Jan 15, 2008
- 15,235
Exactly this!
Unless it's just a figure of speech being used, why would they actually interview him for the job?
Have they really not seen enough?, or is it just an excuse for another jolly up and that feeling of importance that the suits enjoy so much?
The latter. They want to don their blazers and have a series of meetings about it.
Apart from the England job and a short spell with Sunderland, when he was the last English manager to win the league championship, I guess.
1066familyman
Radio User
- Jan 15, 2008
- 15,235
In fact Howard Wilkinson is a million miles away from the dinosaur he's often perceived to be. Very open minded and innovative as a manager/coach apparently. Not saying it always worked out for him, but a closed minded traditionalist he certainly ain't.
Just putting this out there, and may be completely naive, but why should a successful club manager be an almost necessary prerequisite for the England manager's job? After all, the national squad's games are either friendlies or tournaments, very different from league football, surely?
My view (maybe completely wrong) is that is massively beneficial if you have managed in Europe due to the style of football
HastingsSeagull
Well-known member
As with last time round there is one candidate to interview and that is Bielsa
Mo Gosfield
Well-known member
- Aug 11, 2010
- 6,364
The most important thing to them seems to be brand England. The FA is an expensive operation to run and they need to maximise revenue. Qualifying for tournaments is the pre-requisite, as this gets the fans on board with tickets and merchandise and to some extent stimulates the armchair public into spending money.
Progress to the later stages of tournaments is fine. They pretty much max out on revenue then, Winning is not the be all and end all. They rely on the fans having short memories. A few months after abject failure, Wembley is near full again for qualifiers.
Postman Pat
Well-known member
In which case we have no chance of ever hiring an English manager again, none of them get the best jobs in the premier league, and very few manage abroad. We sacked the last one with European experience because he had a rubbish tournament and got beat by Iceland.....
Pavilionaire
Well-known member
- Jul 7, 2003
- 31,278
I don't understand the FA's determination to "go English". Surely you go after the best person for the job?
There's nothing on Southgate's CV to suggest he is the best man for the job.
I have nothing against the man, this is just pure common sense.
The correct thing to do would be to speak to Wenger's team and see if he wants the job at the end of this season with Southgate as caretaker until them. They don't owe Southgate anything - if he does OK then he'll get a decent club job out of it that he'd otherwise have had no chance of getting.
Having Wenger at the helm makes England a very different animal indeed. England's problem is a fragile mentality at tournaments - bottom line is I can see a repeat of Iceland under Southgate but not under Wenger.
There's nothing on Southgate's CV to suggest he is the best man for the job.
I have nothing against the man, this is just pure common sense.
The correct thing to do would be to speak to Wenger's team and see if he wants the job at the end of this season with Southgate as caretaker until them. They don't owe Southgate anything - if he does OK then he'll get a decent club job out of it that he'd otherwise have had no chance of getting.
Having Wenger at the helm makes England a very different animal indeed. England's problem is a fragile mentality at tournaments - bottom line is I can see a repeat of Iceland under Southgate but not under Wenger.
1066familyman
Radio User
- Jan 15, 2008
- 15,235
And you think Wenger can cure a fragile mentality
I'm not so sure he can.Besides which, I'd be amazed if Wenger would ever take the England job. If he was going to go into International management then surely he could easily have the France job at some point (not sure how long Deschamps has on his current contract). And have you seen that French squad lately
It's a no brainer as to which to choose.
Yeh, because Wenger's Arsenal definitely do not have a habit of falling apart the moment the season gets serious...
Wenger is tactically clueless, he plays the same way everytime no matter what. See his record of never beating Mourinho. England under Wenger would be no different (results wise) to England under Hodgson. First team set up properly in defence beats England, same as it always is, bar v Germany 2010.
England's weaknesses are all the same as Wenger's, defensive organisation, tactical awareness and flexibility.
It is all academic though, England do not have the players and will never have the players until youth coaching is sorted out in this country. All the rest is window dressing.
smudge
Up the Albion!
Gareth Southgate absolutely screams "Meh"
Iggle Piggle
Well-known member
- Sep 3, 2010
- 5,988
The only way Gareth would not get the job.
'Morning Gareth'
'Jesus Howard, I'm gasping. You got a pint of wine handy?
'No problem Gareth. Just an informal interview, we just want to make sure you fit the bill after the Sam debacle, 3rd party ownership and all that'
'Piece of piss getting round them, if you need to know anything nudge, nudge'
'That wasn't what I meant Gareth. After Glenn, just wanted a quick conversation about your religious beliefs'
'Ha. No worries there Howard. I don't believe spazzes did anything wrong in a previous life'
'OK thanks Gareth'
'Nah worry yourself Howard'
'Morning Gareth'
'Jesus Howard, I'm gasping. You got a pint of wine handy?
'No problem Gareth. Just an informal interview, we just want to make sure you fit the bill after the Sam debacle, 3rd party ownership and all that'
'Piece of piss getting round them, if you need to know anything nudge, nudge'
'That wasn't what I meant Gareth. After Glenn, just wanted a quick conversation about your religious beliefs'
'Ha. No worries there Howard. I don't believe spazzes did anything wrong in a previous life'
'OK thanks Gareth'
'Nah worry yourself Howard'
Last edited:
Leekbrookgull
Well-known member
English FA thinking,Southgate gets the post and is given a deal up to Euro 2020 however unsprisingly as we all know England fail to get out of the group in the 2018 W/Cup and Southgate waits for his pay-off.