dougdeep
New member
All done and dusted by tea. Told you.
Presume they will pick the same 12 for the next test match but as Lloyd said Collignwood is so out of form but is there another batsman about who is in form and could take his place..............................Matt Prior.
Would drop Anderson for Tremlett. Otherwise would keep it the same.
Is that the same Anderson who was the only fast bowler on either side to take five wickets in the match? and the one who took five wickets in the last test match too?
Presume they will pick the same 12 for the next test match but as Lloyd said Collignwood is so out of form but is there another batsman about who is in form and could take his place..............................Matt Prior.
Is that the same Anderson who was the only fast bowler on either side to take five wickets in the match? and the one who took five wickets in the last test match too?
or the same one who has just clean bowled Redmond and McCullum with pacey and late-swinging deliveries in the opening overs of their first innings? (and who also contributed 28 very welcome runs with the bat in a 76 run 8th wicket partnership?)
Not sure I would drop Collingwood just yet, I think if I was to bring in Prior it would still probably be for Ambrose.
Its the James Anderson who bowled 20 overs in the first innings for 118 runs, despite bowling on a pitch offering extraordinary pace and bounce. (Yes, he picked up four wickets but you are conveniently forgetting that three of those were the last three batsmen, including Chris Martin - widely regarded as the poorest batsman in the history of test cricket).
It is the same James Anderson who is a proven failure in test cricket and has a test bowling average of 37. Compare that average to Sidebottom (26), Hoggard (30), Simon Jones (28), Flintoff (32), the much-criticised Harmison (31) and the player I am suggesting replacing him with - Chris Tremlett (29). Oh, and all bar two of the above have a better batting average than Anderson.
But if you are happy to stick by a player who go for SIX runs an over on a seamer friendly pitch at home to the SEVENTH best test side in the world, before picking up three easy wickets against those batting giants Mills, O'Brien and Chris f***ing Martin then I am very glad that you are not a selector.
PS - well done on conveniently ignoring my earlier post, in response to you, on page 3.
Would drop Anderson for Tremlett. Otherwise would keep it the same.