Dunk or Greer

[Pinkie Brown]

Dunk is getting back to his best and on his performance last night, fully deserves to keep the shirt.

 

[backson]

Either.

That's what a squad is for

 

[Seagull kimchi]

Ooops - didn't have my glasses on - thought the choice was Skunk or Beer. Voted for Skunk.

 

[Cowfold Seagull]

Greer; get rid.

Sorry, but that's a ridiculous post. whilst admitting that Greer hasn't exactly been on top form for the last few games he is still playing well enough to warrant his inclusion in our starting line-up, is an inspirational figure and of course our captain. Yes Lewis did very well as his stand in last night, and is possibly the man who will take over from him, but not quite yet.

 

[Cheeky Monkey]

Dunk - use him or lose him.

 

[Munkfish]

Dunk should be given a chance as Greer cost us 2 points against Reading, Dunk's performance last night was decent and he is only going to learn from Upson.

Greer s first choice for me, but doesnt mean Dunk shouldnt get a chance.

 

[Albion_Dave]

Dunk for me but pretty sure GG will be straight back in. The experience of playing next to Upson for the rest of the season would bring him on leaps & bounds.

 

[Machiavelli]

Dunk is the future. Don't think he should be dropped after being one of our best players last night, but I'll trust Oscar in whatever he decides to do.

This. I'd go with Dunk on Saturday. But if Oscar thinks otherwise, then I'm wrong.
By the way, when is his contract to?

 

[sully]

No doubt there will be some people still churning out the theory that Dunk gives up at least one howler a game based purely on his sending off at Selhurst while ignoring similar mistakes from Greer.

Indeed. Let's not forget why Dunk got his chance last night.

I'd definitely pick Dunk from now on, as he appears to have leapt back to the classy player he looked like when he first got into the first team and is getting better. Greer scares the life out of me at least once a game when he seems unable to decide which way to pass (and always opts for backwards and into trouble).

 

[scooter1]

Based on his performance last night, Dunk.
However, he is prone to lapses in concentration and could just as easily f**k it up royally 30 seconds after making a heroic tackle

 

[Perfidious Albion]

If Dunk is the future - (maybe ? ) but Greer is now.. A very effective centre half both as a ball player and a leader.

Scooter put it well about Dunk

However, he is prone to lapses in concentration and could just as easily f**k it up royally 30 seconds after making a heroic tackle

 

[S'hampton Seagull]

I voted Dunk, but with Saturday's game in mind only. Harsh to drop him after playing so well.

 

[Albumen]

Greer for this season, Dunk will hopefully take over long term.

 

[TSB]

Club Captain won't be dropped.
Dunk's time is coming, though. Next year he'll be first choice.

 

[perseus]

Very close run choice. I have plumped for Greer. I can't get the Palace sending off out of my mind.

It really depends who plays defensive midfield. If Andrews is covering I tend to prefer Dunk.

 

[RexCathedra]

Defense is at least as much brains as feet. Pace isn't everything...

 

[Kumquat]

Dunk was actually superb against Hull too when we lost. I think he looks a much more confident player on top of the technical ability he has always had. I think his time has come and I would be more comfortable with him than Greer for the rest of the season.

 

[surlyseagull]

this

The Greer hate is foolish - him + upson are statistically the best centre backs in the division. Dunk is the future and was excellent tonight but Greer is a top championship centre back, one of our best players and captain

Of course this is right ,how can people write of and nit pick a defence like ours ,there isnt a championship manager that wouldnt have Greer in his squad .Yes Dunk is the future perhaps and he had a good game and as a player I do like him ,but its Greer for me at the moment ,the stats dont lie .

 

[Hamilton]

I don't hate Greer, but he's not exactly inspiring an attacking brand of football. Maybe if he realises he isn't guaranteed a place he'll step it up a bit.

You've got to give Dunk another crack of the whip.

 

[LowerWesty]

Indeed. Let's not forget why Dunk got his chance last night.

I'd definitely pick Dunk from now on, as he appears to have leapt back to the classy player he looked like when he first got into the first team and is getting better. Greer scares the life out of me at least once a game when he seems unable to decide which way to pass (and always opts for backwards and into trouble).

This, but it might be more than once.