Current Market value of our players....

[Bring back Bryan wade!!]

What do you think our players are currently worth, factoring in age, experience, potential and obviously ability. I would say as follows:

Ankergren £500k
Brezovan £200k
Calderon £700k
Painter £500k
Greer £500k
El-Abd £350k
Dunk £750k
Elphick £200k
Bridcutt £1m
Dicker £500k
Sparrow £300k
Vincelot £400k
Buckley £1m
Noone £1m
Navarro £150k
CMS £2.5m
Barnes £1m
Hoskins £1m
Bergkamp £250k
Cook £150k

Obviously Lua Lua omitted as not our player.

Have I been over generous or have I under valued any individuals?

 

[Biscuit]

I don't think Bergkamp is worth anything near that. I also think you've underestimated Buckley.

If:
Calderon £700k
Painter £500k
Greer £500k
went for those prices I would be GUTTED. You couldn't replace them for those fees.

 

[Bring back Bryan wade!!]

I am curious Biscuit, what would you value the 3 of them at?

I don't think Bergkamp is worth anything near that. I also think you've underestimated Buckley.

If:
Calderon £700k
Painter £500k
Greer £500k
went for those prices I would be GUTTED. You couldn't replace them for those fees.

 

[Commander]

I don't think Barnes is worth £1 million by any stretch of the imagination.

I think Noone might be worth a lot more than £1 million come the end of the season.

 

[Biscuit]

I am curious Biscuit, what would you value the 3 of them at?

Sorry it was quite a negative post! I'd say you got most spot on. Personally, I'd have Bergkamp on about 75k and Calderon 900k, Painter 650k and Greer 700k to be honest! I think they are all great at what they do and think we'll have a good season because of them. A good season in the Championship could bring us real glories so their prices would have to reflect that!

 

[Bring back Bryan wade!!]

I don't think Barnes is worth £1 million by any stretch of the imagination.

I think Noone might be worth a lot more than £1 million come the end of the season.

20 goals last season, a goal and an assist already this season..... I reckon he is worth a million.

 

[severnside gull]

Realistically I think it is easy to over-value so I would go as follows:

Ankergren £300K
Brezovan £50K
Calderon £800K
Painter £250K
Greer £750K
Dunk £750K
el Abd £300K
Elphick £200K
Cook £125K
Navarro £100K
Bridcutt £800K
Vincelot £200K
Dicker £400K
Sparrow £200K
Buckley £1.5m
Noone £1m
Hoskins £750K
Mackail-Smith £3m
Barnes £750K

 

[Bring back Bryan wade!!]

Only 250k Painter Severnside??

Realistically I think it is easy to over-value so I would go as follows:

Ankergren £300K
Brezovan £50K
Calderon £800K
Painter £250K
Greer £750K
Dunk £750K
el Abd £300K
Elphick £200K
Navarro £100K
Bridcutt £1m
Vincelot £200K
Dicker £400K
Sparrow £200K
Buckley £1.5m
Noone £1m
Hoskins £500K
Mackail-Smith £3m
Barnes £1m

 

[Commander]

20 goals last season, a goal and an assist already this season..... I reckon he is worth a million.

Statistically he looks like he is, but he played in a superb team last year that created a hell of a lot of chances. And he only hit 20, not 35. I think he's a decent prospect, but he's only worth a million if someone will pay a million, and at the moment I don't think anyone would.

 

[seagullsovergrimsby]

On the basis Judas is valued at £1.5M then CMS has to be rated as an £8M+ player

 

[severnside gull]

Only 250k Painter Severnside??

Age and mobility /pace limits his transfer value I think although not his value to us which I would agree is much higher. I have revised a few downwards on exactly that basis - the style we play gives some players more value to us than we could ever realise in the market as very few sides play our style of football.

 

[southern_sid]

Remember Zamora coming in for just over 100k, i thought we were f***ing minted when he signed.

how times change.

 

[Biscuit]

Age and mobility /pace limits his transfer value I think although not his value to us which I would agree is much higher. I have revised a few downwards on exactly that basis - the style we play gives some players more value to us than we could ever realise in the market as very few sides play our style of football.

Even with that considered I'd value him at about double that!

 

[Tomo1794]

Ankergren £200k
Brezovan £0k
Calderon £750k
Painter £500k
Greer £750k - £1m
El-Abd £275k
Dunk £750k
Elphick £150k
Bridcutt £1m
Dicker £450k
Sparrow £300k
Vincelot £400k
Buckley £1m
Noone £1m
Navarro £100k
CMS £2.5m
Barnes £500k
Hoskins £600k
Bergkamp £150k
Cook £150k

 

[nevergoagain]

Would be gutted to see Dunk go for 750k, we'd have to be mad to do that.

 

[Mellotron]

What price would any of you let Forster-Caskey go at?

 

[Amex_Charlie]

Ankergren- 450k
Brezovan- 100k
Cálderon- 800k
Painter- 600k
Greer- 800k
Dunk-800k
Cook-150k
El-abd- 350k
Elphick- 200k
Bridcut- 1m
Vincelot- 400k
Navaro- 200k
Dicker- 550k
Sparrow- 600k
Lualua- 1.75m
Buckley- 1.2m
Noone- 1m (if he keeps up good form)
CMS- 2.75m
Hoskins- 800k
Barnes- 700k
Bergkamp- 400k

 

[brightonrock]

Save the fringe players like Cook/Navarro, I can't see us accepting 250k for anyone regularly in our matchday 16. We're a Championship side now, I'm sure for the likes of Painter/Calderon/Dicker, TB would laugh off a bid of 250-400k. It'd have to be half a mill before we started even talking. The exceptions to this are the keepers- both are unproven at Champ level and the wrong side of 30 (which I know isn't such a problem for a keeper, but still) so I doubt would command more than a quarter of a mill.

Ankergren- 200k
Brezovan- 50k

Defence -
Dunk- 1m (great prospect)
Painter- 500-750k (still young enough to have plenty of years ahead, doubts remain over pace)
Greer- 500-750k (Captain fantastic but not the most agile guy - plus 30-odd, would be surprised to get 1m)
Calderon- 500k (29/30 now so won't get too close to 1m in the market)
El-Abd- 500k (very important to Gus' style, versatile and has Champ experience)
Elphick- 250k (fringe player but still young enough to get a decent fee - especially as Tunnicliffe cost 100k!)
Cook- 100k (still very much development squad, will he get a chance in the cups this year?)

Midfield-
Bridcutt- 1.5m (our key player IMO, makes us tick)
JFC- 1m (such potential, just a question of whether he'll get a look-in...)
Noone- 750k (bought for 300k so you can at least double it, plus more for what he gives us - a new club hero?)
Dicker- 750k (signed a new contract, possible outside bet for the Ireland squad?)
Sparrow- 500k (versatile, proven Champ player but 28/29 now and in the last year of his deal?)
Navarro- 100k (coming back from injury, on a short-term contract)

Upfront-
Barnes- 750k (20 goals at his age is a great achievement but I think he's in the last year of his contract?)

You can roughly double what we've paid for our new signings as we just wouldn't let them go having just spent money on them...
CMS- bought for 2.5m so easily 4-5m
Buckley- bought for 1m but looks brilliant so 2-2.5m
Hoskins- bought for 500k but still young so 1-1.5m
Vincelot- bought for 100k but very versatile so 300-500k
Bergkamp- almost impossible to judge until we've seen him in some capacity. U21 international though so probably around 250-500k?

 

[algie]

Some of those prices are stupid. For instance both of our keepers i would value at £0 along with Sparrow,

 

[Munkfish]

How are people putting a value cook at all?

lets be honest if a league 1 or 2 club put a bid in for him i could see him going for 20-50k tops.

same with Bergkamp, although no way will we be selling him.

Navarro will not be valued at much either due to only having one year on his contract 50-80k tops