I would say Thomson as he was captain at Falkirk mind you all the above would be great to get the arm band the one I would plum for apart from Thomson would be Nicky Forster
I'm sure someone soon will be commenting something along the lines of:
It Has To Be Nathan Elder, Forster Couldn't Captain A Dinghy...Blah...Blah...Blah...
I would choose Thomson over Forster or Kuipers. Not sure why but I have always preferred to have the captain in defence or midfield (not at one end of the pitch).