Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Politics] Brexit

If there was a second Brexit referendum how would you vote?


  • Total voters
    1,101








WATFORD zero

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 10, 2003
27,792
Jesus you talk some nonsense.

So which part of this nonsense do you think isn't needed ?

How do you see a British (or NI as WTO require a hard border) customs post operating under WTO 'no deal' rules by 20th March 2019 ?

Because you wouldn't be calling for something you don't understand would you.
 
Last edited:










Klaas

I've changed this
Nov 1, 2017
2,667


DIFFBROOK

Really Up the Junction
Feb 3, 2005
2,267
Yorkshire
View attachment 101334

So what happens when MP's vote against no deal

Do you just ignore parliament??

I think this is one of the most important statements the PM has said in recent weeks. It is clear from this, that in the event that negotiations between UK and EU do not produce an agreement, then the UK will simply not fall into a "No deal" situation. The situation will come back to the House of Commons.

There is certainly no majority for a particular deal, but there is certainly a majority against a "No deal". Tory MPs will not vote for a Election, but I can see a Peoples vote more likely than ever.

I think it was William Hague who said that should hard core Brexiteers push too much, they may end up with no Brexit at all.
 




nicko31

Well-known member
Jan 7, 2010
18,600
Gods country fortnightly
I think this is one of the most important statements the PM has said in recent weeks. It is clear from this, that in the event that negotiations between UK and EU do not produce an agreement, then the UK will simply not fall into a "No deal" situation. The situation will come back to the House of Commons.

There is certainly no majority for a particular deal, but there is certainly a majority against a "No deal". Tory MPs will not vote for a Election, but I can see a Peoples vote more likely than ever.

I think it was William Hague who said that should hard core Brexiteers push too much, they may end up with no Brexit at all.

The EU know this and can just hold there ground and wait, they know May always gives in eventually

Seems like 2 outcomes..

a) May gets a deal at the last minute, finally giving ground. Then a close run thing with parliament and unlikely to get through without a fair few Labour votes

or

b) No deal, parliament reject this and then who knows. If there was People's vote it can't happen fast, will take ages. A50 would need to be extended, we would need European elections again!!!

What a absolute mess the Tories have made of us. Meanwhile inward investment dries up and the Brexit bill goes up and up. Wait for the tax rises to pay for unfunded promises...
 


Gwylan

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
31,840
Uffern
b) No deal, parliament reject this and then who knows. If there was People's vote it can't happen fast, will take ages. A50 would need to be extended, we would need European elections again!!!

The indications coming from the EU suggest they would be happy to extend it. Various heads of government have said, over the past two years, that they don't want the UK to leave and if there were a possibility of the UK remaining, they'd be keen to accommodate that.
 


WATFORD zero

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 10, 2003
27,792
The indications coming from the EU suggest they would be happy to extend it. Various heads of government have said, over the past two years, that they don't want the UK to leave and if there were a possibility of the UK remaining, they'd be keen to accommodate that.

It's certainly in the EU's interests to extend because if one of their nearest and largest neighbours were to blow their own brains out (economically), there would still be a hell of a dry cleaning bill.

We saw this all before in the run up to the end of phase 1 negotiations in December last year. At the last minute TM folds and agrees to what the EU want. It was Friday 9th Dec 2017 (the last day of the phase 1 negotiations) that we folded last time, if I remember rightly.
 
Last edited:




nicko31

Well-known member
Jan 7, 2010
18,600
Gods country fortnightly
The indications coming from the EU suggest they would be happy to extend it. Various heads of government have said, over the past two years, that they don't want the UK to leave and if there were a possibility of the UK remaining, they'd be keen to accommodate that.

Yes they might extend A50 in some circumstances, but not just to accommodate government incompetence as it comes with a lot of hassle.

Britain is sick of Brexit but so is the EU, they want to see an end point.
 


Blue Valkyrie

Not seen such Bravery!
Sep 1, 2012
32,165
Valhalla
It seems the swivel eyed Brextremists want Bercow out - as he decides if Parliament get the power to stop a *no deal*.

Let's hope he digs in and doesn't resign to be replaced by an ERG Stooge.
 


Gwylan

Well-known member
Jul 5, 2003
31,840
Uffern
It seems the swivel eyed Brextremists want Bercow out - as he decides if Parliament get the power to stop a *no deal*.

It's pretty difficult to remove a Speaker. An MP could call a vote of no confidence (which Bercow may not allow to be raised) but even if he did, the government front bench would be obliged to support him - as would many back benchers (Bercow has been particularly good at raising backbench concerns, so there's goodwill there). Don't forget the ERG are very much a minority (and a small minority at that) in Parliament.
 




beorhthelm

A. Virgo, Football Genius
Jul 21, 2003
36,031
It seems the swivel eyed Brextremists want Bercow out - as he decides if Parliament get the power to stop a *no deal*.

Let's hope he digs in and doesn't resign to be replaced by an ERG Stooge.

no speaker, elected by all of parliament, is going to be the stooge of a small group. by convention/rules of the house they keep debate open and support the House over the government.
 


CHAPPERS

DISCO SPENG
Jul 5, 2003
45,101
John Mann, who broke the party whip to support the Tories in July, has been granted an urgent question about John Bercow.

Coincidence, I'm sure.
 




Simster

"the man's an arse"
Jul 7, 2003
54,983
Surrey
So with no support for Chequers and no support for "no deal" at the Commons, and no wiggle room on the Irish border thanks to her DUP chums, May is a busted flush.

Who was it yesterday who likened her to a chess player with just her king remaining, moving all around the board one square at a time waiting for the inevitable to happen? Tremendous analogy and 100% correct. If she doesn't engineer it so that she goes back to the people, she is an idiot. But regardless of that, her party are now proven incompetents and have no business governing the country IMO. They are only there by default.
 






Ernest

Stupid IDIOT
Nov 8, 2003
42,748
LOONEY BIN
So with no support for Chequers and no support for "no deal" at the Commons, and no wiggle room on the Irish border thanks to her DUP chums, May is a busted flush.

Who was it yesterday who likened her to a chess player with just her king remaining, moving all around the board one square at a time waiting for the inevitable to happen? Tremendous analogy and 100% correct. If she doesn't engineer it so that she goes back to the people, she is an idiot. But regardless of that, her party are now proven incompetents and have no business governing the country IMO. They are only there by default.

She has no moves left, goes one way the EU stop her, goes the other the ERG stop her, goes another the DUP stop her and goes one last way Parliament will stop her. This goes back to triggering Article 50 without having a concrete plan in place, she should have negotiated the withdrawal bill before this and then used the 2 year period to tie up the loose ends of a trade deal.

And Universal Credit has been delayed , what was that about a 'coalition of chaos' and 'strong and stable government' ???
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here