Buckley vs Forest/Dan Harding deserves a mention, I think.
Giroud was exceptional and might get my vote, but my nagging doubt is that from memory he was being marked by Adam El Abd, who by that stage was well beyond the ability to keep quiet a borderline world class playerMentioning the Giroud performance in this line-up feels a bit like after timing as his career had a significant renaissance long after his expected prime. On that day, he was undoubtedly very good and his goal from the edge of the area was indeed top quality. But I felt at the time we had coped with him quite well all game until he did that.
That game was also notable for it being Ulloa's debut just as we were all getting a bit sick of the labrador being a bit shit. When CMS eventually came on as a late sub, he theatrically flopped looking for an equalising penalty when otherwise well placed. I turned round to @hans kraay fan club and we both immediately acknowledged that if that chance had fallen to Leo or even Barnes, they'd have just shrugged off the defender and smashed it in. I know he scored a couple of great goals, but I still get pissed off when I think of CMS.
Definitely not with the amount of timewasting but anyway there have been many more notable goalkeeper performances over the years, keepers always seem to save their performance of the season for the AmexAs for opposition, how about that performance from Trafford? Must be up there.