Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Andy Naylor



crasher

New member
Jul 8, 2003
2,764
Sussex
I find this board's obsession with Andy Naylor a bit bizarre. He's a journalist, he tries to figure out what's going on by asking questions, doing some research, tapping up contacts. And yes, keeping an eye on a message boards (he's he'd be a bit rubbish if he deprived himself of that option among many). He know a bit more about what what's happening at the club than most of us, and he has to stick his neck out in print. Unlike the poseurs on here - there's comeback for him when he gets it wrong. Which it will do sometime.

But most of all - like us - he's an observer. What he writes has minimal influence on what goes on at the club or who it signs.

It's not his job to be liked by the club. In fact, he shouldn't be. There's an old saying in newspapers that if the local council is happy with your coverage then you're doing something wrong. Asking difficult questions, putting an eye-catching slant on things - that's what makes us read journalists. And, by the way, he's been watching Albion for more years than many of us so don't underestimate what he does know.
 




The_Viper

Well-known member
Oct 10, 2010
4,345
Charlotte, NC
The honest answer is we both don't know, but I trust on TB and have every confidence he will deliver in terms of ensuring we have a competitive squad come Sep 1st.

Do I believe we have other targets ? Yes. Does that make me gullible ? No.

You'd be pretty naive to believe we won't strengthen in the coming weeks IMO

It's a shame that the season will be five games in by September 1st.
 


S'hampton Seagull

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2003
6,946
Southampton
Ward is a done deal.... (Watch this space)

But I'm suggesting that there are a few targets higher up the pecking order on the 'wish list'

A central midfielder, centre half and target man possibly.
You said we would hear something today, we haven't.
 


Dan Aitch

New member
May 31, 2013
2,287
Naylor is the lead football journalist on the biggest local paper to our team.

We all hear and have views on rumours that come and go.

None of us expect the biggest football journalist on our team's local paper to spout unsubstantiated rubbish.

If none of the three (Ward, Clayton, Baldock) sign then in my opinion Naylor has made a fool of himself, at a time of the season when we should be expecting him to be reliable, calming, and insightful.

If he's only pandering to those who have no access, or choose not to access, NSC, Twitter, etc. then he's playing to a minority... and a bigger idiot than his 'trio sign' story suggests. Either way, he's either desperate or foolish... as I will have proven myself to be if all three eventually sign for the Albion... but then being a credible football journalist isn't my job.
 


Mike Small

Well-known member
Dec 26, 2008
2,980
He's a poor journalist left even further behind as the club and the club's PR grows. He's also a poor writer and not liked by other Argus staff. He should go back to Stoke. The season he leaves is the season we make the Prem.
 






crasher

New member
Jul 8, 2003
2,764
Sussex
Naylor is the lead football journalist on the biggest local paper to our team.

We all hear and have views on rumours that come and go.

None of us expect the biggest football journalist on our team's local paper to spout unsubstantiated rubbish.

If none of the three (Ward, Clayton, Baldock) sign then in my opinion Naylor has made a fool of himself, at a time of the season when we should be expecting him to be reliable, calming, and insightful.

If he's only pandering to those who have no access, or choose not to access, NSC, Twitter, etc. then he's playing to a minority... and a bigger idiot than his 'trio sign' story suggests. Either way, he's either desperate or foolish... as I will have proven myself to be if all three eventually sign for the Albion... but then being a credible football journalist isn't my job.

A lot of truth in what you say - if his "trio about to sign" story is all wrong, he'll have to live with the consequences.

But - journalists don't just make things up. He'll have based that story on what he was hearing from people at the club (either officially or unofficially) and stretched it as far as it would reasonably go. That's what newspapers do.

Where I think you're wrong is when you say it's his job to be calming. That's not his job at all - he's not employed by the club and he has no responsibility to us fans. Ultimately, we choose to read him or not - it's our call. Perhaps some will stop reading him if none of those three player sign. Me, I'll keep reading the Argus stories - usually, they tell me more than I already know.
 


crasher

New member
Jul 8, 2003
2,764
Sussex
He's a poor journalist left even further behind as the club and the club's PR grows. He's also a poor writer and not liked by other Argus staff. He should go back to Stoke. The season he leaves is the season we make the Prem.

So Andy Naylor is stopping us getting to the Premier League? FFS.
 




Not Andy Naylor

Well-known member
Dec 12, 2007
8,999
Seven Dials
Not really, other people 'in the know' echoed Naylors sentiments and have been sympathised with. Curious.

Pretty much this. If you compare his success rate in predicting comings and goings with that of many national journalists whose job it is to make up, sorry, report transfer stories, then he's pretty good. I can't rememver which genius it was on the Star who said categorically that Southampton had given up on Graziano Pelle and were turning their attention to Connor Wickham. But Pelle signed the very next day.
 




Not Andy Naylor

Well-known member
Dec 12, 2007
8,999
Seven Dials
He's a poor journalist left even further behind as the club and the club's PR grows. He's also a poor writer and not liked by other Argus staff. He should go back to Stoke. The season he leaves is the season we make the Prem.

That has to be wrong. There are hardly any Argus staff left to dislike anyone.
 








tigertim68

Well-known member
Sep 3, 2012
2,627
The honest answer is we both don't know, but I trust on TB and have every confidence he will deliver in terms of ensuring we have a competitive squad come Sep 1st.

Do I believe we have other targets ? Yes. Does that make me gullible ? No.

You'd be pretty naive to believe we won't strengthen in the coming weeks IMO

shame the season starts on saturday not on Sept 1st , the season will be one ninth over , by the time according to TB , that our signings will be complete
 




B.W.

New member
Jul 5, 2003
13,666
The honest answer is we both don't know, but I trust on TB and have every confidence he will deliver in terms of ensuring we have a competitive squad come Sep 1st.

Do I believe we have other targets ? Yes. Does that make me gullible ? No.

You'd be pretty naive to believe we won't strengthen in the coming weeks IMO

I'm sure we will (but losing faith day by day). However, end of Aug really isn't good enough when your squad is as depleted as ours is.
 


Napper

Well-known member
Jul 9, 2003
24,461
Sussex
If his relationship with the club has broken down then he has to make stuff up . I suspect our directors never wanted to work with the argus
 












Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here