Not knowing much about guitars I'm not going to vote but I rememeber as a kid everyone talked about the Fenders. However, I'm sure someone in the know told me that Fenders were for people who knew nothing about guitars and just wanted to look good.
Now it may surprise you fourteenth that I will have a different answer here...
EITHER
Gibson Casino - As played here by the impeccably cool Daniel Kessler from the impeccably cool INTERPOL.
OR
Gretsch White Falcon - as played by John Frusciante of the Red Hot Chili Peppers. Say what you want about the Chilis good or bad John is a guitar genius.
Sully Fenders are quality guitars. As are Gibsons. There is a ridiculous amount of snobbery in the guitar world, I did partake in that just a moment ago when I slagged off Les Pauls (Gibson).