[Albion] Albion 2017-18 discipline watch
- Thread starter Bozza
- Start date
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Mackenzie
Old Brightonian
Dunk, Duffy and Murray are the three in most danger. I find it quite comforting that we have Hunemeier, Goldson and Hemed in reserve if needed.
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
Duffy 4 - and 1 away from a ban ?
Murray 3
Murray 3
- Thread starter
- #24
Murray also on 4 now I think.
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
Yes indeed. He got another yellow v Stoke.
- Thread starter
- #26
Two players now walking the yellow card TIGHTROPE...
Ryan 0
Bruno 2
Schelotto 0
Duffy 4
Dunk 2
Goldson 0
Hunemeier 0
Suttner 0
Bong 1
Propper 1
Stephens 0
Knockaert 3
Izquierdo 0
March 1
Gross 1
Brown 0
Murray 4
Hemed 0
Ryan 0
Bruno 2
Schelotto 0
Duffy 4
Dunk 2
Goldson 0
Hunemeier 0
Suttner 0
Bong 1
Propper 1
Stephens 0
Knockaert 3
Izquierdo 0
March 1
Gross 1
Brown 0
Murray 4
Hemed 0
The Camel
Well-known member
This is confusing.
Can someone point out if this correct?
If you get to 5 yellows before December 31st, you get a one match ban.
If you don't get get to 5 before that date, you don't get a ban unless you reach 10 yellows in the season.
And if you have reached 5, you get a second ban if you reach 10. (Is the second ban another one game, or is it more severe?)
As an aside, where do red cards fit in to this system?
Joe Gatting's Dad
New member
Usually(last year) one match ban for 5 cards and two matches for 10 cards
- Thread starter
- #29
1 game ban if 5 cards by 19 games / 31st December (which one is unclear)
2 game ban if 10 cards by 32 games (you can get the 5 card ban AND the 10 card ban or just the one)
15 cards before the end of the season results in a hanging or something similarly tough (3 game ban probably).
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
The card amnesty is after the Watford game on 19th December ( if I have read Andy Naylor correctly ).
The Camel
Well-known member
And do reds (whether straight red or two yellows) count for the totals?
Or are they ignored as the players will get a separate ban for getting sent off?
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
How can you be so sure? Maybe he was having a proper middle of the night wee in the desert. Watch out for those rattlers, AZ!
Last edited:
AZ Gull
@SeagullsAcademy @seagullsacademy.bsky.social
This is incorrect. A one match ban is served when a player receives two yellows (and is sent off) in the same match. As such, a punishment is meted out for both cards and they are not used in the tally of accumulated bookings that potentially lead to a ban.
AZ Gull
@SeagullsAcademy @seagullsacademy.bsky.social
The FA, this season, has published a "Player Essentials" document which includes the following slide:-
So, it would seem that from this season the FA has moved to a system based primarily upon number of matches played (but still with a firm cut-off date).
My interpretation is this:-
1) Player receiving fifth booking in 19th (or earlier) league fixture played before Dec 31 - one match ban
2) Player receiving fifth booking in 20th (or later) league fixture played before Dec 31 - no ban
3) Player receiving fifth booking in 19th (or earlier) league fixture played AFTER Dec 31 (unlikely, would need multiple postponements) - no ban
For Albion, based upon our current fixture list, our 19th league match of the season is the Watford home game on Dec 23rd.
It would seem that there has been some confusion at the Argus about this - in the paper this morning the following article appeared:-
The next 8 matches take us up to the Newcastle fixture on Dec 30, ie the Argus were assuming the cut-off was Dec 31.
However, earlier today Andy Naylor tweeted:-
[TWEET]935115099211255808[/TWEET]
So, it would seem that someone had a word in Andy's shell-like, and he now interprets the system in a similar manner to that outlined in this post.
- Thread starter
- #36
Post-Palace:
Ryan 0
Bruno 2
Schelotto 0
Duffy 4
Dunk 3
Goldson 0
Hunemeier 0
Suttner 0
Bong 1
Propper 1
Stephens 0
Knockaert 3
Izquierdo 1
March 1
Gross 1
Brown 0
Murray 4
Hemed 0
Ryan 0
Bruno 2
Schelotto 0
Duffy 4
Dunk 3
Goldson 0
Hunemeier 0
Suttner 0
Bong 1
Propper 1
Stephens 0
Knockaert 3
Izquierdo 1
March 1
Gross 1
Brown 0
Murray 4
Hemed 0
Machiavelli
Well-known member
Thanks AZ, as ever.
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
Bruno up to 3 now ?
- Thread starter
- #39
Yep:
Ryan 0
Bruno 3
Schelotto 0
Duffy 4
Dunk 3
Goldson 0
Hunemeier 0
Suttner 0
Bong 1
Propper 1
Stephens 0
Knockaert 3
Izquierdo 1
March 1
Gross 1
Brown 0
Murray 4
Hemed 0
Blue Valkyrie
Not seen such Bravery!
4 more games before the Card Amnesty.
Worst case : Dunk and Duffy suspended for the same game.
Worst case : Dunk and Duffy suspended for the same game.