Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Player ratings vs Newcastle (a -- FA Cup fifth round)



Machiavelli

Well-known member
Oct 11, 2013
18,260
Fiveways
Bart 8 -- very composed, claimed some high balls
Lamptey 6 -- had a really good game up until that moment. His first yellow was clear although a little unfortunate as Gordon shoved him. We can have more complaints about the second one although he gave Taylor the option just five minutes after giving Gordon his comeuppance at a riled SJP
JPvH 8 -- immense performance
Webster 8 -- also immense. Really unlucky to get a card
Estupinan 6 -- some great stuff, some really wayward stuff too
Baleba 6 -- off it today and arguably luckier to stay on the pitch than Tariq. Showed some of his quality despite all that
Hinshelwood 9 MotM -- what a display, played in multiple positions, recycled the ball intelligently, had some good blocked attempts. One of the most intelligent players in the PL. At 19.
Minteh 7 -- nice run for the goal and got the shot off early enough. Nice that he can learn from his penalty mistake without it impacting the result. Typically impressive work rate.
Rutter 7 -- great strength, work rate and usual joy. Didn't quite generate enough quality
Mitoma 6 -- shame he didn't have more chances to run at Trippier
Joao Pedro 8 -- lovely assist and despite being utterly shot was intelligent in what he did during ET

Subs:
Gomez 7
Gruda 5 -- good for the pre-assist and tracked back well, but too many poor finishes and passes
Wieffer 8 -- broke things up really well and intelligent play
Welbeck 8 -- what a finish
Solly 7 -- professional contribution, allowed us to keep our shape and delightful assist

Why won't the FA allow an additional sub during ET when other competitions do?
 








Mike Small

Well-known member
Dec 26, 2008
3,267
Bart 8 - great punches
Lamptey 5 - played well but got sent off when he shouldn't
JPvH 8 - incredible at the end. Favourite moment was realising none of our midfielders were closing them down from their corner - he absolutely sprints out and wins the foul. Schar should have been booked
Webster 8 - solid again
Estupinan 6 - one great pass. Otehr times a bit sloppy
Baleba 6 - he wasn't on it today. Taking too long on the ball. Easily could have been sent off. Daft
Hinshelwood 8 - great positionally. Gave away one soft foul. MOTM today
Minteh 7
Rutter 7 - found space well but didn't do all that much with it
Mitoma 6 - one great cross
Joao Pedro 7 - great assist. Too many touches at other times

Subs:
Gomez 7
Gruda 6 - good pass to March. Tidy but we need more pace and power from him
Wieffer 7 - great cameo again. Intelligent player. He was full back and CM during this game
Welbeck 8
Solly 7 - brilliant assit and one lovely run

Fab - 9. Great subs at the right time.
 


One Teddy Maybank

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Aug 4, 2006
23,776
Worthing
Bart 8 - great punches
Lamptey 5 - played well but got sent off when he shouldn't
JPvH 8 - incredible at the end. Favourite moment was realising none of our midfielders were closing them down from their corner - he absolutely sprints out and wins the foul. Schar should have been booked
Webster 8 - solid again
Estupinan 6 - one great pass. Otehr times a bit sloppy
Baleba 6 - he wasn't on it today. Taking too long on the ball. Easily could have been sent off. Daft
Hinshelwood 8 - great positionally. Gave away one soft foul. MOTM today
Minteh 7
Rutter 7 - found space well but didn't do all that much with it
Mitoma 6 - one great cross
Joao Pedro 7 - great assist. Too many touches at other times

Subs:
Gomez 7
Gruda 6 - good pass to March. Tidy but we need more pace and power from him
Wieffer 7 - great cameo again. Intelligent player. He was full back and CM during this game
Welbeck 8
Solly 7 - brilliant assit and one lovely run

Fab - 9. Great subs at the right time.
These.
 






















Skaville

Well-known member
Jun 10, 2004
10,326
Queens Park
Bart 8 -- very composed, claimed some high balls
Lamptey 6 -- had a really good game up until that moment. His first yellow was clear although a little unfortunate as Gordon shoved him. We can have more complaints about the second one although he gave Taylor the option just five minutes after giving Gordon his comeuppance at a riled SJP
JPvH 8 -- immense performance
Webster 8 -- also immense. Really unlucky to get a card
Estupinan 6 -- some great stuff, some really wayward stuff too
Baleba 6 -- off it today and arguably luckier to stay on the pitch than Tariq. Showed some of his quality despite all that
Hinshelwood 9 MotM -- what a display, played in multiple positions, recycled the ball intelligently, had some good blocked attempts. One of the most intelligent players in the PL. At 19.
Minteh 7 -- nice run for the goal and got the shot off early enough. Nice that he can learn from his penalty mistake without it impacting the result. Typically impressive work rate.
Rutter 7 -- great strength, work rate and usual joy. Didn't quite generate enough quality
Mitoma 6 -- shame he didn't have more chances to run at Trippier
Joao Pedro 8 -- lovely assist and despite being utterly shot was intelligent in what he did during ET

Subs:
Gomez 7
Gruda 5 -- good for the pre-assist and tracked back well, but too many poor finishes and passes
Wieffer 8 -- broke things up really well and intelligent play
Welbeck 8 -- what a finish
Solly 7 -- professional contribution, allowed us to keep our shape and delightful assist

Why won't the FA allow an additional sub during ET when other competitions do?
you have everything spot on bar Gruda, who really grew into the game, and Wieffer, who just doesn’t warrant an 8. Both 6-7 for me
 
Last edited:


borat

Well-known member
Jul 16, 2003
699
Gruda seems reluctant to shoot when in good positions. However I thought he made a good overall contribution today. His time will come.
Skillset is there but thought he looked like he lacked fitness and stamina especially on one run when he lost the ball and was running in treacle.
 




Terry Butcher Tribute Act

Well-known member
Aug 18, 2013
3,930
I thought that was Gruda's best game. Real, positive energy and driver getting us forward when others were flagging.

Bart 8
Lamptey 6 (would have been 8 if he'd not lunged in, tough game)
Webster 9
Van Hecke 9 - motm for those tackles at the end
Pervis - 7
Baleba 7
Hinshelwood 8
Mitoma 5
Minteh 7
Rutter 6
Pedro 7

Gruda 7
March 7 what an assist
Welbeck 7 what a goal
Gomez 7
Weiffer 7
 












jcdenton08

Joel Veltman Fan Club
NSC Patron
Oct 17, 2008
16,223
Bart - 8
Lamptey - 5
JPvH - 7
Webster - 8
Perv - 7
Baleba - 6
Hinsh - 8
Minteh - 7
Rutter - 6
Mitoma - 4
Pedro 7

Subs:
Gomez - 7
Gruda - 7
Welbeck - 8
March - 7
Wieffer - 7

Subs won us the game.
 


Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports


Top
Link Here