[Football] Salah or Mbappe ?

Randy McNob

> > > > > > Cardiff > > > > >

Jun 13, 2020

4,801

• Feb 24, 2025

• #1

If you could have either player right now, who would you take?

 

Is it PotG?

Thrifty non-licker

Feb 20, 2017

26,467

Sussex by the Sea

• Feb 24, 2025

• #2

Can either play LB?

 

beorhthelm

A. Virgo, Football Genius

Jul 21, 2003

36,299

• Feb 24, 2025

• #3

Salah - proven in this league, Mbappe might be another excellent player that doesn't fit.

 

Ⓩ-Ⓐ-Ⓜ-Ⓞ-Ⓡ-Ⓐ

Hove / Παρος

Apr 7, 2006

6,894

Hove / Παρος

• Feb 24, 2025

• #4

A salad bap? Mnnn, no thanks.

 

N

nsclurker

Well-known member

Apr 3, 2018

621

• Feb 24, 2025

• #5

Salah all day long.

 

Sarisbury Seagull

Solly March Fan Club

NSC Patron

Nov 22, 2007

15,577

Sarisbury Green, Southampton

• Feb 24, 2025

• #6

Salah.

He’s actually under rated. Goals, assists, work rate, incredible football brain. Astonishing player, one of the best ever.

 

D

Dave Fishwick

Well-known member

Feb 28, 2021

1,633

London

• Feb 24, 2025

• #7

I still think Mbappe is the better player. Salah might be maturing with age (becoming less selfish) but if I was taking one, Mbappe (longevity also a factor)

 

H

Han Solo

Well-known member

May 25, 2024

3,931

• Feb 25, 2025

• #8

Mbappe.

Not because he's necessarily better but because he's more than 6 years younger... making it a choice between "world class striker for 2-3 seasons or for 7-8 seasons".

 

S

sussex_guy2k2

Well-known member

Jun 6, 2014

4,727

• Feb 26, 2025

• #9

Han Solo said:

Mbappe.

Not because he's necessarily better but because he's more than 6 years younger... making it a choice between "world class striker for 2-3 seasons or for 7-8 seasons".

Click to expand...

Exactly this. I think Salah is one of the top 2-3 players in the world, but so is Mbappe, so his age wins out.