[Albion] Our best Premier League 11

T

The Optimist

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Apr 6, 2008

2,799

Lewisham

• Today at 10:48 AM

• #1

The would you want Bissouma back thread got me thinking. What is our best Premier League 11?

The rules are it’s how they played for us that counts and in the position they played for us (so no Gyokeres or Ben White at right back).

I’m heading off to think about my choices.

 

drew

Drew

NSC Patron

Oct 3, 2006

23,743

Burgess Hill

• Today at 10:59 AM

• #2

The Optimist said:

The would you want Bissouma back thread got me thinking. What is our best Premier League 11?

The rules are it’s how they played for us that counts and in the position they played for us (so no Gyokeres or Ben White at right back).

I’m heading off to think about my choices.

Click to expand...

Why no Ben White at full back?

 

T

The Optimist

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Apr 6, 2008

2,799

Lewisham

• Today at 10:59 AM

• Thread starter
• #3

drew said:

Why no Ben White at full back?

Click to expand...

Because he didn’t play full back for us.

 

T

The Optimist

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Apr 6, 2008

2,799

Lewisham

• Today at 11:01 AM

• Thread starter
• #4

My first stab at an 11 is:

Verbruggen

Veltman Dunk White Cucurella

Caicedo Mac Allister

Gross Pedro Mitoma

Welbeck

I reserve the right to change my mind.

 

B

big nuts

Well-known member

Jan 15, 2011

4,880

Hove

• Today at 11:07 AM

• #5

Gk Verbruggen
Rb Veltman
Lb Cucurella
Cd Dunk
Cd Van Hecke
Cm Caicedo
Cm MacAllister
Rm March
Lm Mitoma
Str Pedro
Str Welbeck

Bench

Sanchez
Bruno
Colwill
White
Bissouma
Baleba
Gross
Trossard
Murray

 

Harry Wilson's tackle

Harry Wilson's Tackle

NSC Patron

Oct 8, 2003

56,706

Faversham

• Today at 11:14 AM

• #6

big nuts said:

Gk Verbruggen
Rb Veltman
Lb Cucurella
Cd Dunk
Cd Van Hecke
Cm Caicedo
Cm MacAllister
Rm March
Lm Mitoma
Str Pedro
Str Welbeck

Bench

Sanchez
Bruno
Colwill
White
Bissouma
Baleba
Gross
Trossard
Murray

Click to expand...

Good call but it is a squad game for me and all of those (plus others in peak form) could do a job. I would not include Bruno in that list - his passing was erratic.

So I can't answer this any more than I can name my Perfect Day.

 

H

Han Solo

Well-known member

May 25, 2024

2,917

• Today at 11:16 AM

• #7

The Optimist said:

Because he didn’t play full back for us.

Click to expand...

eees complicated

He kind of played right back. Ish. Sometimes.

Anyway:

Sanchez

White, Van Hecke, Dunk

Gross, Bissouma, Caicedo, Mac Allister, Cucurella

Trossard, Mitoma

Harsh on Welbeck but..

 

Joey Jo Jo Jr. Shabadoo

I believe in Joe Hendry

Oct 4, 2003

12,210

• Today at 11:19 AM

• #8

4-2-3-1 Formation

GK Verbruggen
RB Veltman
CB White
CB Dunk
LB Cucurella
CM Mac Allister
CM Caicedo
RW Joao Pedro
ACM Gross
LW Mitoma
CF Murray

Subs
Sanchez
JPVH
Pervis
March
Welbeck
Baleba
Trossard
Bissouma
Bruno

Close calls between Veltman and Bruno for RB. Murray and Welbeck for striker.

 

T

The Optimist

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Apr 6, 2008

2,799

Lewisham

• Today at 12:05 PM

• Thread starter
• #9

Han Solo said:

eees complicated

View attachment 194066

He kind of played right back. Ish. Sometimes.

Anyway:

Sanchez

White, Van Hecke, Dunk

Gross, Bissouma, Caicedo, Mac Allister, Cucurella

Trossard, Mitoma

Harsh on Welbeck but..

Click to expand...

Surely you need more presence upfront than Trossard and Mitoma offer. Love the midfield, it would absolutely boss the middle against almost everyone.

 

H

Han Solo

Well-known member

May 25, 2024

2,917

• Today at 12:11 PM

• #10

The Optimist said:

Surely you need more presence upfront than Trossard and Mitoma offer. Love the midfield, it would absolutely boss the middle against almost everyone.

Click to expand...

I just think those two are too good to leave out. But yeah maybe Welbeck for Mitoma.

 

T

theboybilly

Well-known member

Apr 25, 2013

6,289

Along the Shoreham Road in er, Shoreham

• Today at 12:38 PM

• #11

Verbruggen
Veltman
JPvH
Dunk
Estupinan
March
Gross
Caicedo
Mac Allister
Mitoma
Welbeck

Subs:

Steele
Cucarella
Igor
Burn
Hinshelwood
Mwepu
Trossard
Ferguson
Murray

 

Weststander

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Aug 25, 2011

69,868

Withdean area

• Today at 2:52 PM

• #12

—————-Verbruggen
Veltman Dunk Colwill Estupinan
March MacAllister Caieco Mitoma
——————Gross
—————-Welbeck

Very deliberately choosing Estupinan over Cucu, as this should be based on form for us. Estupinan 22/23 was more consistent and a better defender than Cucu 21/22 …. R5/TS experts in 22/23 casually mentioned Estupinan as the best LB in the PL.

Goalkeeper is tricky. Steele’s distribution exemplary, key to our greatest 90’ performances.

 

Albion my Albion

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Feb 6, 2016

19,922

Indiana, USA

• Today at 3:27 PM

• #13

The Optimist said:

I reserve the right to change my mind.

Click to expand...

You can only change your mind if you remember to take it with you and don't leave it behind while watching a film.


Manager for this exercise must be the former Ghanan manager and the greatest "keeper upper" in the PL.

 

Not Andy Naylor

Well-known member

Dec 12, 2007

9,017

Seven Dials

• Today at 3:39 PM

• #14

Steele

Veltman Dunk Colwill Cucurella

Caicedo Mac Allister

March Gross Mitoma

Murray

Subs: Verbruggen, JPVH, Estupinan, Baleba, Welbeck, Lallana, Bissouma, Joao Pedro, Trossard.

Putting aside my dislike of certain players who have left, I think this is 'best'. Murray is in because he is the only striker we've ever had where I expected him to score when he had a chance. I expected all the others to mess it up somehow, and they usually did.

 

GT49er

Well-known member

NSC Patron

Feb 1, 2009

49,443

Gloucester

• Today at 4:04 PM

• #15

Not Andy Naylor said:

Steele

Veltman Dunk Colwill Cucurella

Caicedo Mac Allister

March Gross Mitoma

Murray

Subs: Verbruggen, JPVH, Estupinan, Baleba, Welbeck, Lallana, Bissouma, Joao Pedro, Trossard.

Putting aside my dislike of certain players who have left, I think this is 'best'. Murray is in because he is the only striker we've ever had where I expected him to score when he had a chance. I expected all the others to mess it up somehow, and they usually did.

Click to expand...

Almost this, but White (RCB) and Dunk (LCB) for me if going four at the back - Colwill was never ours. The season we had White didn't we mostly play three at the back to accommodate him? I'm pretty sure he played RB on occasions too.
Would like to squeeze in Mwepu too, but not quite sure how - and Sanchez for Steele.

Sanchez
White Dunk Cucurella
March Caicedo Mac Allister Mitoma
Mwepu Gross
Murray​

 

B

Brian Fantana

Well-known member

Oct 8, 2006

7,577

In the field

• Today at 4:05 PM

• #16

Bart

Veltman Dunk Colwill Cucurella

Caicedo Mac Allister

March Gross Mitoma

Murray

 

7

7dialssouthpaw

Active member

Sep 10, 2022

233

• 34 minutes ago

• #17

I like balance and combinations so:

CB's Dunk'nDuffy (kept us up, hard AF, so good together got goals too)

Sanchez behind them: we noticeably improved when he started playing.

FBs - The 2 Catalans: Bruno i Cucurella (Bruno better attacker than Velts, Cucu had a near-perfect season with us at LB) - Spain really knows how to churn out full-backs, eh...

MID: Can't beat Mac and Moi - well done to the algorithm

Outside: RM Gross and LM Tross - game winners both

Up top: Murray and JP. As someone else said, you always felt Muzza would score. JP just edges other forwards with the win/score penalty routine, but Welbs was close.

----

CBA with bench

 

Jeremiah

John 14 : 6

Mar 15, 2020

2,594

Hove

• 30 minutes ago

• #18

Am I allowed Wayne Bridge ? as he was a Premier League player who played for us but not while we were in the Premier.

 

Dave the OAP

Well-known member

Jul 5, 2003

46,788

at home

• 11 minutes ago

• #19

Interesting not many people going for Trossard.

how many players names can you spell incorrectly

verbruggen
bruno
dunk
van hecke
cucarella
gross
mwepu
macalister
caicedo
murray
mitoma

subs

trossard
bissouma
pedro
veltman
adringa
enciso
bunanotte
pervis

 

stewart12

Well-known member

Jan 16, 2019

1,948

• 1 minute ago

• #20

Dave the OAP said:

Interesting not many people going for Trossard.

Click to expand...

Unfortunately it's hard to get both Trossard and Mitoma into the line up