Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

Register Log in

[Football] When is a punch NOT a sending off offence ?



B

BluesRockDJ

Well-known member
Jan 24, 2020
1,333
So West Ham concede a penalty for the 'keeper punching the Arsenal player, instead of the ball, from a corner. The ref gives a penalty and a booking to the 'keeper. If that happened anywhere else on the pitch, surely that's a red ?
 








Triggaaar

Triggaaar

Well-known member
Oct 24, 2005
53,658
Goldstone
BluesRockDJ said:
So West Ham concede a penalty for the 'keeper punching the Arsenal player, instead of the ball, from a corner. The ref gives a penalty and a booking to the 'keeper. If that happened anywhere else on the pitch, surely that's a red ?
Click to expand...


I'm getting my pitchfork!

METALMICKY said:
Err I'll have a go at this one. Is it because goalkeepers are entitled to attempt to punch the ball in their box whilst it's pretty much a no no for outfielder players to attempt that anywhere.

You have not been charged for this :ffsparr:
Click to expand...

Shit.
 


Albion my Albion

Albion my Albion

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Feb 6, 2016
19,957
Indiana, USA
It's a judgement call. Is the offensive player putting his face in a position to be punched where you expect a goalkeeper to punch it out? If yes, no foul at all. If the offensive player is avoiding to strike the ball with his head and the keeper strikes his head or another part of his body with a punch than it would most likely be a red card.

When was it that Dunk had to play the end of a match in goal when, I believe, Sanchez got a red card for a deliberate challenge?
 




mejonaNO12 aka riskit

mejonaNO12 aka riskit

Well-known member
Dec 4, 2003
22,029
England
BluesRockDJ said:
So West Ham concede a penalty for the 'keeper punching the Arsenal player, instead of the ball, from a corner. The ref gives a penalty and a booking to the 'keeper. If that happened anywhere else on the pitch, surely that's a red ?
Click to expand...
That's like saying "why is the keeper allowed to keep on catching the ball in his box? If a player did that anyone else on the pitch it would be a booking"
 








Herr Tubthumper

Herr Tubthumper

Well-known member
NSC Patron
Jul 11, 2003
63,106
The Fatherland
Greg Bobkin said:
These days, if you're a goalkeeper and you accidently punch an oppo player in the head, you get arrested and thrown in jail.
Click to expand...
I’d have been Ang Lee if the ‘keeper was given a red.
 




M

maffew

Well-known member
Dec 10, 2003
9,071
Worcester England
There's a thought, a speedball/football/boxing combo game would be a good watch. Give the goalies big boxing gloves and legitimise landing a punch on players, set pieces would be awesome
 








R

ROSM

Well-known member
Dec 26, 2005
6,877
Just far enough away from LDC
I am going to defend fabianski here. I think he was nudged off balance and therefore to still get such power in the punch he deserved a medal not a yellow card
 


You must log in or register to reply here.
Albion and Premier League latest from Sky Sports

Share this page


Top
Link Here