Bring the skipper back, or never change a winning team?
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
[Albion] If Dunk is fit, would you start him?
- Thread starter Bozza
- Start date
The elephant in the room is the issue of whether Dunk is reaching a point where our defense doesn't operate 'like that' any more.
I felt recently the defense had a Dunk-shaped hole in it, but that was the Liverpool cup game I think....
So I am fence, but voted for the second option
I felt recently the defense had a Dunk-shaped hole in it, but that was the Liverpool cup game I think....
So I am fence, but voted for the second option
Brian Fantana
Well-known member
I don't think any of the defence deserves to be dropped for Dunk right now.
Uh_huh_him
Well-known member
- Sep 28, 2011
- 12,418
I would like to give the players returning from international duty in South America/Africa/Japan a bit of a breather tbh.
Move Igor to LB and Dunk back in.
Move Igor to LB and Dunk back in.
Left Footer
Well-known member
Does Igor deserve to be dropped? Probably not.
Dunk could be a bit rusty so i would bench him tomorrow.
Dunk could be a bit rusty so i would bench him tomorrow.
Is it PotG?
Thrifty non-licker
His presence is worth a bit on top of everything else.
I love Dunky but (whisper it quietly) I honestly think he is starting to be found a bit lacking in the style Hurzeler wants to play.
Just my opinion of course, but we miss him less now than we would have 3 years ago
Just my opinion of course, but we miss him less now than we would have 3 years ago
Barham's tash
Well-known member
This is a big test of Fab's man management skills and his authority within the squad I feel. Perhaps a bit of a sliding doors moment.
Bring Dunk back straight away does have a bit of a one rule for some and another for others type of feel especially after the defence's recent performances.
IMO he shouldn't start and IF Igor doesn't have the best game against Bournemouth then Dunk comes back in would be my approach.
More generally Igor and JPVH appear to have developed a bit of an understanding. Also I used to feel Dunk being suspended or injured (albeit rarely) meant psychologically the opposition got a boost but now i'm not quite so sure.
Never change a winning team for me.
Bring Dunk back straight away does have a bit of a one rule for some and another for others type of feel especially after the defence's recent performances.
IMO he shouldn't start and IF Igor doesn't have the best game against Bournemouth then Dunk comes back in would be my approach.
More generally Igor and JPVH appear to have developed a bit of an understanding. Also I used to feel Dunk being suspended or injured (albeit rarely) meant psychologically the opposition got a boost but now i'm not quite so sure.
Never change a winning team for me.
Thunder Bolt
Silly old bat
This. Coming back from injury and playing 90 mins won’t help the team at all. Put him on the bench and bring him on when he’s needed.
JPvH and Igor are just developing a really good understanding. I don’t think Bournemouth away (they beaten Citeh & Arsenal at home) is the game to change things.
I think Dunk needs to be gradually reintroduced. Let his work harder and get fitter. That said, I’d probably stick him back in for Stains.
I think Dunk needs to be gradually reintroduced. Let his work harder and get fitter. That said, I’d probably stick him back in for Stains.
BrightonCottager
Well-known member
Please bring him back for your game on Dec 5th.;-)
Milano
Well-known member
This
Marshy
Well-known member
I would not hesitate to put him back in the side if fit.
Your best players come back in regardless for me.
Add that hes the skipper and its a no brainer.
Your best players come back in regardless for me.
Add that hes the skipper and its a no brainer.
Bench. Get some minutes for now and then start v Palace perhaps
AmexRuislip
Retired Spy 🕵️♂️
Morning Fabian
Jimmy Grimble
Well-known member
Ultimately he’s a better player than Igor.
FH has an easy ‘out’ for not putting him straight back in the side though with his recent injury.
My prediction is that it’ll be Igor tomorrow and then Dunk will be back in next week.
FH has an easy ‘out’ for not putting him straight back in the side though with his recent injury.
My prediction is that it’ll be Igor tomorrow and then Dunk will be back in next week.
Tom Hark Preston Park
Will Post For Cash
- Jul 6, 2003
- 72,719
Maybe time to start using him as a squad player to be introduced as and when the situation demands. The post-Dunk era has to start sometime, same as the post-Duffy era did
This is the first time I'd say no. He needs to play his way back in. Igor and JPVH will go off the boil at some point. I also think Igor has earnt tthe right to not be whipped straight out the moment he has one iffy game too.