[Other Sport] Haka (or not)

aolstudios · 2024-11-15T14:11:39+0000

Following on from Seagulls fan Joe Marler's controversial words last week (& coincidentally, the Bluesky thread). I'm not a Haka fan (despite, or maybe because of being in a small room with Buck Shelford & some mates performing it a few years ago) but this is superb... https://bsky.app/profile/ziibiing.com/post/3law66jmgjk2n

Swimboy64 · 2024-11-15T15:01:31+0000

100% yes from me

Jack Straw · 2024-11-15T15:06:38+0000

It's a big fat YES from me.

Iggle Piggle · 2024-11-15T15:37:11+0000

It would have made the football better last night if the Greeks had started luzzing plates and we did a spot of Morris dancing before kick off.

Motogull · 2024-11-15T18:18:34+0000

Facing the Haka has to be one of your best memories if you play at that level. Not many will experience it.

Eeyore · 2024-11-15T19:13:38+0000

Joe has a tendency to speak what's on his mind in a, shall we say, inappropriate ways sometimes. He can be very funny at times, but he can also be a bit rude.

The haka is part of New Zealand heritage and is a famous sight in rugby. Nothing wrong with the responses either. All theatricals.

Iggle Piggle · 2024-11-15T19:49:15+0000

I'd also like to point out how shit it used to be.

Dad dancing.

shingle · 2024-11-15T20:53:29+0000

Fu**ing love Joe Mahler

AstroSloth · 2024-11-15T21:00:22+0000

aolstudios said:
Following on from Seagulls fan Joe Marler's controversial words last week (& coincidentally, the Bluesky thread). I'm not a Haka fan (despite, or maybe because of being in a small room with Buck Shelford & some mates performing it a few years ago) but this is superb... https://bsky.app/profile/ziibiing.com/post/3law66jmgjk2n

I've never seen a Haka for sports, but I've seen the band Alien Weaponry perform a Haka at the start of their shows.

They're a New Zealand band that often sing in Te Reo Māori and about the history of the indigenous Moari population.

Brian Fantana · 2024-11-15T21:11:44+0000

I totally appreciate the cultural significance of the Haka to New Zealand and the other South Sea islands. It certainly adds some colour to test match rugby. However, I don't really see why teams are a) forced to line up and watch it and b) not be able to respond to it themselves.

BN9 BHA · 2024-11-15T21:33:03+0000

Brian Fantana said:
I totally appreciate the cultural significance of the Haka to New Zealand and the other South Sea islands. It certainly adds some colour to test match rugby. However, I don't really see why teams are a) forced to line up and watch it and b) not be able to respond to it themselves.

Spot on, the England team should just be allowed to go and warm up well away from the NZ team, stay in the dressing room and let them get on with their dance act or all hold up large cards saying BOTHERED ? :wink:

Finch · 2024-11-15T21:36:01+0000

Haka means more to me than a national sing-song. If watching delayed I tend to fast forward through the anthems as they are boring as shit. I think at some point we've got to address dual language anthems as well, are we going to sing our anthem twice forever? I'd axe our english national anthem in a heartbeat to shorten it down.

It's pretty understandable that there is going to be people out there who don't get the Haka or enjoy it on the other side when its not their culture.

Brian Fantana said:
I totally appreciate the cultural significance of the Haka to New Zealand and the other South Sea islands. It certainly adds some colour to test match rugby. However, I don't really see why teams are a) forced to line up and watch it and b) not be able to respond to it themselves.

In terms of a) if you want to challenge a nation you take on that nation and culture. You can turn your back on it, its disrespectful but no one is stopping you.

In terms of b) you can if its of cultural significance / contextually appropriate. A few things have been tried, Australia did Waltzing Matilda for a while in response to the Haka but IRB eventually ruled it wasn't really a culturally significant song. If England wanted they could put together something that is culturally important and contextually appropriate.

aolstudios · 2024-11-15T21:55:04+0000

Motogull said:
Facing the Haka has to be one of your best memories if you play at that level. Not many will experience it.

Better memory to win the game, I reckon

aolstudios · 2024-11-15T21:56:53+0000

Eeyore said:
Joe has a tendency to speak what's on his mind in a, shall we say, inappropriate ways sometimes. He can be very funny at times, but he can also be a bit rude.

The haka is part of New Zealand heritage and is a famous sight in rugby. Nothing wrong with the responses either. All theatricals.

I think Joe pricking the bubble of over reverance is to be encouraged, frankly

Motogull · 2024-11-15T22:03:06+0000

aolstudios said:
Better memory to win the game, I reckon

Yeah, but statistically unlikely.

aolstudios · 2024-11-15T22:07:13+0000

Motogull said:
Yeah, but statistically unlikely.

All the more reason to cherish it.
& not intimidated by silly, deliberately off-putting theatrics

Triggaaar · 2024-11-15T22:47:50+0000

It's a no from me

BN9 BHA · 2024-11-15T22:48:58+0000

Village People Dancing GIF by Saturday Night Live

Eeyore · 2024-11-15T22:57:57+0000

Brian Fantana said:
I totally appreciate the cultural significance of the Haka to New Zealand and the other South Sea islands. It certainly adds some colour to test match rugby. However, I don't really see why teams are a) forced to line up and watch it and b) not be able to respond to it themselves.

But I'm struggling to see why anyone would have an issue with it. It's been around for decades. Part of the spectacle. They are not forced to do anything as far as I am aware. They just aren't allowed to cross the half way line (which there was no need to). The arrow was fine. For me it's a non issue.

The French knew what to do- without breaking the rules. Pure theatre

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Other Sport] Haka (or not)

Well-known member

Well-known member

I look nothing like him!

Well-known member

Todd Warrior

Colonel Hee-Haw of Queen's Park

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

DOCKERS

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Todd Warrior

Well-known member

Well-known member

DOCKERS

Colonel Hee-Haw of Queen's Park

Share this page