[Albion] Eric Dier anyone?

Pavilionaire · Wednesday at 2:45 PM

IMHO it's one of those where your initial reaction is no, but then when you think about it there are a number of good arguments in favour:

1. Cover for Baleba - This is a weakness for us, when Carlos gets subbed at the business end of the game. Dier has the physicality and the nous to cover, and - I think - a better option than Moder, Milner or (based on limited evidence, admittedly) Wieffer.
2. Cover at centre back.
3. Ability to drop into a back 3 if we change system.
4. Great passing range for a defensive player.
5. A good presence at corners.
6. International and European experience.
7. Apparently, he speaks fluent Portuguese, so useful when communicating tactics with Igor and Joao Pedro.
8. Motivation - Tuchel now England manager, he got the best out of him at Bayern, a possible recall as utility player not out of the question.

Surf's Up · Wednesday at 3:05 PM

dejavuatbtn said:
No one wants Dier ‘ere.

I wonder how long you've been waiting to crack that one out

severnside gull · Wednesday at 3:18 PM

Speaks German.
That’s the only thing I can think of to recommend him

Stato · Wednesday at 3:30 PM

Pavilionaire said:
7. Apparently, he speaks fluent Portuguese, so useful when communicating tactics with Igor and Joao Pedro.

And German and Spanish apparently. That's invaluable. He could speak to Igor, Estupinan, Gruda, Pedro, Enciso, all of the English speakers, Hurzeler and half the coaching team in their own languages. Imagine how many times that could come in useful.

"Minhas sinceras desculpas pelo meu erro Igor."

"Sí Pervis, era demasiado lento para reaccionar allí."

"Entschuldigen Sie mich kurz Fabian. Ich werde einen unserer Unterstützer angreifen."

WATFORD zero · Wednesday at 3:43 PM

hans kraay fan club said:
John Byrnes Mullet said:

I think he would do ok for us with taking away the pressure of playing for a top 6 club. He is not particularly quick but neither is Dunk or Igor. Whatever we definitely need to be looking at signing a new CB next season or bringing through a youngster.

Click to expand...

or JPVH. Which is EXACTLY why the additions in this area DO need to be.

And O/T

I've thought this about our three CBs up until Saturday, but there were a couple of occasions where Igor absolutely flew across to make interceptions/tackles. I'm beginning to wonder whether I've misjudged just how quick he is

UnhingedSeagull94 · Wednesday at 3:47 PM

Not for me. Never been that impressed with him, bang average at best. We have Dunk as the old head at the back, with 2 fantastic CBs in Igor and JP. We should stick to our model and buy players with potential, not donkeys like ED.

Is it PotG? · Wednesday at 3:50 PM

Dier gets a special mention in this PP vid.

jackanada · Wednesday at 3:57 PM

No. Still remember Jonathan Liew writing that Steven Alzate (currently playing for Hull) made it look like Dier was playing in a suit if armour.

Mike Small · Wednesday at 5:23 PM

No, no, no.

hans kraay fan club · Wednesday at 5:36 PM

Jackthelad said:
Milner and Welbeck were different. Dyer is sort of player a team like West Ham spunks all their wages on and then he goes and gets injured.

That's 'different' from Milner, how, exactly?

Bozza · Wednesday at 5:42 PM

Terry Butcher Tribute Act said:
So many on here saying no "too slow" who would have wet themselves of we'd got 36 year old Mats Hummels in the summer.

Dier would be ideal this season I think. Senior pro, solid enough at this level, versatile, presumably not expecting to start every game. The two positions we look light in numbers are centre back and physical DM, he can do both

Funnily enough whilst searching for more on the slowest players in the Bundesliga, I found an article where Manchester United were being discouraged from signing Mats Hummels as he is too slow.

The article is 10-years old.

From our senior pool of players, we have lost Groß and Lallana, and it feels like Milner is very unlikely to get another year beyond this one. Veltman is also out of contract in the summer.

We do seem to like having a few wise old heads to balance out all the exuberant youngsters that pack our squad, and Dier does seem to have the kind of profile that fits with that.

jcdenton08 · Wednesday at 5:44 PM

Terry Butcher Tribute Act said:
So many on here saying no "too slow" who would have wet themselves of we'd got 36 year old Mats Hummels in the summer.

Dier would be ideal this season I think. Senior pro, solid enough at this level, versatile, presumably not expecting to start every game. The two positions we look light in numbers are centre back and physical DM, he can do both

In fairness, Hummels and Dier aren’t exactly in the same talent bracket

Triggaaar · Wednesday at 6:16 PM

I can't believe we'd be interested

Weststander · 2024-11-14T23:46:57+0000

The ESL boo-boys would have to tread very carefully.

Harry Wilson's tackle · 2024-11-14T23:59:47+0000

hans kraay fan club said:
Not for me, Clive.

He's very slow. We do not need more slow defenders.

This

Reddleman · 2024-11-15T00:09:02+0000

I will wager that so many of the people saying no said exactly the same thing when we signed Welbeck, Lallana and Milner. These signings are as much of the clubs plans as the wonder kids from further afield.

Harry Wilson's tackle · 2024-11-15T00:10:27+0000

Albion Robster said:
I'd rather him Adam Webster as our fourth choice centre-back than Eric Dier.

And let's run that by the team again, this time in English.

HastingsSeagull · 2024-11-15T06:07:40+0000

Good player, good age, good experience but what's his pace like? Then the inevitible #wages

superseagull1994 · 2024-11-15T06:10:09+0000

God no, not for me

Herr Tubthumper · 2024-11-15T06:14:01+0000

jackanada said:
No. Still remember Jonathan Liew writing that Steven Alzate (currently playing for Hull) made it look like Dier was playing in a suit if armour.

I love Jonathan Liew

Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊

[Albion] Eric Dier anyone?

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Member

Thrifty non-licker

Well-known member

Well-known member

The voice of reason.

You can change this

Offended Liver Sausage

Well-known member

Well-known member

Harry Wilson's Tackle

Well-known member

Harry Wilson's Tackle

Well-known member

Active member

Well-known member

Share this page