[Music] What is the greatest debut album of all time ?

Nitram

Well-known member

Jul 16, 2013

2,268

• Sep 21, 2024

• #101

Strong arguments for the Stone Roses and Joy Division.
Depending on my mood I would include Madness One Step Beyond, Dire Straits Dire Straights, Hendrix Are you Experienced, and probably my strongest call Led Zeppelin.

 

C

Cosmic Joker

The Motorik

Apr 14, 2010

570

Chichester

• Sep 21, 2024

• #102

Television, Marquee Moon also needs to be on this thread.

 

aolstudios

Well-known member

Nov 30, 2011

5,309

brighton

• Sep 21, 2024

• #103

Cosmic Joker said:

These are all great choices (although I'm less familiar with the Cowboy Junkies one than the others).

I was also going to put forward if you ignore mini albums and go for debut full length then Surfer Rosa may take the prize. Another band around the same time where you can do the same thing and ignore two early mini albums, is My Bloody Valentine with Isn't Anything.

but god, yeah Patti Smith's Horses. Opening with the line "Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine" can't really be topped.

Three debut albums not mentioned yet but should be are The Smiths eponymous (forget about what Morrisey later became), Portishead eponymous and Tricky with Maxinquaye.

Click to expand...

Horses is a top shout

 

Doonhamer7

Well-known member

Jun 17, 2016

1,457

• Sep 21, 2024

• #104

Herr Tubthumper said:

Appetite for Destruction was quite a statement of intent.

Click to expand...

It is a great album - more like most bands 3rd or 4th album when they’ve evolved and matured as songwriters

 

Pevenseagull

meh

Jul 20, 2003

20,708

• Sep 21, 2024

• #105

After due consideration

Throwing Muses

 

Blue3

Well-known member

Jan 27, 2014

5,839

Lancing

• Sep 21, 2024

• #106

stewart12 said:

I was tempted by this but more in terms of it's historical context (the birth of the biggest and most influential band of all time). And whilst it's a pretty good album and has some very good songs on it, I wouldn't rank it that highly by their standards, maybe like their 7th or 8th best album?

Click to expand...

Yes I tend to agree there are some better first albums but none other had such an impact

 

Whitechapel

Famous Last Words

Jul 19, 2014

4,419

Not in Whitechapel

• Sep 21, 2024

• #107

Not sure of the order but they wrap up the Champions League places.

 

aolstudios

Well-known member

Nov 30, 2011

5,309

brighton

• Sep 21, 2024

• #108

Blue3 said:

Yes I tend to agree there are some better first albums but none other had such an impact

Click to expand...

Good point ^