[Albion] Have we, at some point in our seasons in the EFL/EPL, occupied every position between 1-92?

AZ Gull said:

He is, but looking at his account he hasn't visited since the end of September last year.

Click to expand...

Very sensible.

This is exactly the type of question AI was designed to answer, so according to AI (SEE BELOW)

Yes, Brighton & Hove Albion has occupied every position in the English Football League (EFL) table across the club's history. This means they have been at every spot from first to last, spanning multiple tiers of English football over the years.

The club was founded in 1901 and has played in all four divisions of the English football pyramid, including:

• The First Division/Premier League (top tier)
• The Second Division/Championship (second tier)
• The Third Division/League One (third tier)
• The Fourth Division/League Two (fourth tier)

Brighton has experienced promotions, relegations, and various league positions during its time in the English football system. Their rise to the Premier League in recent years marks the peak of their journey, but in past decades, they have also faced struggles, including near relegation from the Football League entirely.

By occupying every position, Brighton is one of the clubs that has experienced the full range of highs and lows in the professional English football league system.

Nathan said:

Depends how you are judging it. Others might argue that 24th in the old div 1 is now effectively 4th in the championship, based on 1-92 positions. Or do you say that bottom of the top division is the same regardless of the numbers in the top division.

Click to expand...

I will stand corrected but I don’t think there was ever a 24 team, ie 46 games, top flight Div 1.

Marlton and Hove Albion said:

This is exactly the type of question AI was designed to answer, so according to AI (SEE BELOW)

Yes, Brighton & Hove Albion has occupied every position in the English Football League (EFL) table across the club's history. This means they have been at every spot from first to last, spanning multiple tiers of English football over the years.

The club was founded in 1901 and has played in all four divisions of the English football pyramid, including:

• The First Division/Premier League (top tier)
• The Second Division/Championship (second tier)
• The Third Division/League One (third tier)
• The Fourth Division/League Two (fourth tier)

Brighton has experienced promotions, relegations, and various league positions during its time in the English football system. Their rise to the Premier League in recent years marks the peak of their journey, but in past decades, they have also faced struggles, including near relegation from the Football League entirely.

By occupying every position, Brighton is one of the clubs that has experienced the full range of highs and lows in the professional English football league system.

Click to expand...

Thank you old boy ️

Think your prompt is dodgy, based on that answer.

Is there an English football team that at some point in their history has resided in every single of the 92 positions in the football league

**Yes, there is.**

**Burnley** is the only English football team that has resided in every single of the 92 positions in the football league throughout their history. This impressive feat highlights their diverse range of performance levels across different eras.


What about Brighton and Hove Albion?


**Brighton and Hove Albion** have indeed achieved a remarkable feat, but they haven't quite reached the same level as Burnley.

While Brighton have climbed from the lowest tiers of English football to the Premier League, they **haven't yet occupied every single position** in the league pyramid. They've consistently performed well in recent years, establishing themselves as a Premier League club, but they haven't faced the same fluctuations in performance as Burnley.

Which all sounds utterly impressive until... This is still a tough question even for AI

Which of the positions have they not resided in

**Brighton and Hove Albion have not resided in the following positions:**

* **League Two**
* **League Three**

They have been in League One, the second tier of English football, but have never played in the lower two divisions. This is a testament to their consistent performance and progress over the years.

I mean of the 92 positions, not the leagues.

**Brighton and Hove Albion have not resided in the following positions:**

* **91st**
* **92nd**

These are the two lowest possible positions in the English football league system. While they have been in the lower divisions, they have never finished in the bottom two positions. This indicates a consistent level of performance even during their time in the lower leagues.

So they have finished in every other position?

**Yes, that's correct.** Brighton and Hove Albion have finished in every position from 1st to 90th in the English football league system throughout their history. This is a significant achievement, showcasing their consistent performance and progress over the years.

Lenny Rider said:

Thank you old boy ️

Click to expand...

That is not a reliable answer.

I don't actually think it's going to be possible for an LLM to answer accurately.

Mr deez said:

Which all sounds utterly impressive until... This is still a tough question even for AI

Which of the positions have they not resided in

**Brighton and Hove Albion have not resided in the following positions:**

* **League Two**
* **League Three**

They have been in League One, the second tier of English football, but have never played in the lower two divisions. This is a testament to their consistent performance and progress over the years.

I mean of the 92 positions, not the leagues.

**Brighton and Hove Albion have not resided in the following positions:**

* **91st**
* **92nd**

These are the two lowest possible positions in the English football league system. While they have been in the lower divisions, they have never finished in the bottom two positions. This indicates a consistent level of performance even during their time in the lower leagues.

So they have finished in every other position?

**Yes, that's correct.** Brighton and Hove Albion have finished in every position from 1st to 90th in the English football league system throughout their history. This is a significant achievement, showcasing their consistent performance and progress over the years.

Click to expand...

Were we not predominantly in 92nd position for the majority of the 96/97 season, but finished in 91st place?

Lenny Rider said:

Were we not predominantly in 92nd position for the majority of the 96/97 season, but finished in 91st place?

Click to expand...

Yes it's clearly wrong, it talks about where we finished and suggests we've also won the league. I don't think an AI answer will be accurate.

Mr deez said:

Yes it's clearly wrong, it talks about where we finished and suggests we've also won the league. I don't think an AI answer will be accurate.

Click to expand...

Having read this thread, I've decided to pick some more tins of tuna up from Sainsbury's on my walk home, to keep me going when AI inevitably flips out and destroys the modern world.

I had a crack on chatgpt; had to wrestle with it a bit:

Chat history

ChatGPT

You said:
Which current English football league teams in the top four divisions (in the Premier league championship, league one and league two) have occupied all 92 league positions in their history?

ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
There is only one team that has occupied all 92 league positions across the top four divisions of English football, from the Premier League down to League Two:

Coventry City
Coventry City is the only club that has held every position from 1st in the top division to 92nd in the fourth division at some point in their history. They achieved this over their long footballing journey, fluctuating across all levels of English league football.

Coventry City has had a rich history, experiencing highs like winning the FA Cup in 1987 and lows such as relegations that saw them tumble down the football league ladder. This unique distinction of occupying all 92 league positions reflects both their struggles and resilience over time.

You said:
Has Brighton not achieved this?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
You’re right to bring up Brighton & Hove Albion! In fact, Brighton has also occupied all 92 league positions in their history. Brighton’s journey through the English Football League has seen them rise from the bottom of the fourth division to the Premier League.

Similar to Coventry City, Brighton has experienced significant highs and lows, including near financial ruin and relegation to the lowest tier, followed by a remarkable ascent to the top division in recent years. This means both Brighton & Hove Albion and Coventry City have occupied all 92 positions in the Football League.

You said:
Apart from Brighton and Coventry which other teams have also done so?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
In addition to Brighton & Hove Albion and Coventry City, there are two more teams that have occupied all 92 positions in the English Football League:

1. Wolverhampton Wanderers (Wolves)
Wolves have experienced a rollercoaster history, playing in all four divisions of English football. They’ve been champions, struggled with relegations, and climbed back up to the Premier League. This varied history has seen them occupy every position from 1st to 92nd at some point.

2. Carlisle United
Carlisle United, although currently outside the top divisions, have also completed the journey through all four tiers of the Football League. They’ve spent time in the top division during the 1970s and have been relegated to the lowest tier, making them one of the few clubs to occupy every league position.

Summary of Teams That Have Occupied All 92 League Positions:
Coventry City
Brighton & Hove Albion
Wolverhampton Wanderers
Carlisle United
These four clubs have navigated the full spectrum of the Football League throughout their histories.


You said:
When did Carlisle occupy first position?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
Carlisle United briefly occupied the 1st position in the First Division (now the Premier League) at the start of the 1974-75 season. After being promoted to the top division for the first time in their history, they won their first three matches of the season, which put them at the top of the league table.

This was a remarkable achievement for the club, but unfortunately, their stay at the top was short-lived. Carlisle couldn't maintain their early form and were eventually relegated at the end of that season, finishing in 22nd place. Despite the relegation, that brief period at the summit of English football remains a historic moment for the club.

You said:
On what date did they occupy first place?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
Carlisle United occupied 1st place in the First Division on 24th August 1974. This came after they won their first three matches of the 1974-75 season, defeating Chelsea, Tottenham Hotspur, and Middlesbrough.

Carlisle's remarkable start to the season saw them briefly sit at the top of English football, though their form soon declined, and they were relegated by the end of the campaign.

Message ChatGPT

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

Carlisle top:

Nathan said:

I hear what you are saying, but then when you are looking up 5th in the old div 1 back in the 80's for example, you are really comparing that with 5th in the premier league which we have been in. Its a bit of fun, so go for it and it will be interesting to see the results. But is 24th in div 1 in the 80's, the same as 4th in the championship.

Click to expand...

24th. in division 1 in the 80s is 24th. out of 92. 4th. in the current Championship is 24th. out of 92. I can't see how 24th. is different from 24th.

I doubt that will be accurate. It's not like AI will be rifling through every league table to answer this question, but will be looking for correlations of words that exist on the internet, and so are likely to be true.

I suspect the works Carlisle first position in the league will exist a few times so is easy for AI to confirm. I suspect it will be harder for it to confirm when Carlisle were 16th, or 72nd etc as there's probably going to be less written data.

Though I suppose they may have specifically programmed AI to understand the context of a sports league over time to get this.

Update: it's all BS. See below. An LLM can't easily solve this as it's based on nearest data points and assumptions. As a previous poster said you just need all the data, and some python.

Please can you list the date that Brighton occupied each of the 92 positions?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
While it would be fascinating to provide a full list of dates for every position Brighton & Hove Albion has occupied, this is extremely difficult because detailed historical league tables for every single matchday over the course of their entire history are not readily available, especially for lower league seasons. Furthermore, the fluctuation of league positions happens frequently during the course of a season, so teams can occupy several positions within just a few months.

However, I can provide a general outline of Brighton's journey through the 92 league positions:

General Milestones in Brighton's History:
Lowest Position (92nd): In the 1996-97 season, Brighton finished 91st in the Football League (24th in the old Division Three). It was during this season they came close to dropping out of the league entirely, needing a last-minute draw on the final day to avoid relegation to the non-league.

Top of the Premier League (1st position): While Brighton have reached the Premier League in recent seasons, they have not occupied the 1st position in the top division during their current stay. However, they have held positions in the top half of the Premier League.

Rise Through the Divisions: After the near collapse in the 1990s, Brighton began a long ascent, winning promotion to higher leagues. They returned to the Championship in the 2010-11 season and eventually secured promotion to the Premier League in the 2016-17 season.

Brighton's Historical League Progression:
1920: Brighton joined the Football League in Division Three South.
1958: The club reached the Second Division (equivalent to today’s Championship).
1983: Brighton reached the top flight (then the First Division) and finished 13th.
1996-97: Brighton dropped to near the bottom of the Football League pyramid, flirting with relegation to non-league.
2017-present: Brighton secured promotion to the Premier League in 2017 and has consistently played in the top division since.
It would be near impossible to track down the exact dates for every single position Brighton has held across the entire 92 spots in the Football League due to the fluctuating nature of league tables and the frequency of matches across decades.

You said:
If you are unable to provide the date for each, then how can you be certain that Brighton did indeed occupy each of the 92 positions?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
You raise an excellent point. The claim that Brighton & Hove Albion has occupied all 92 positions in the Football League is based on general historical analysis rather than a precise match-by-match tracking of their standings.

Clubs like Brighton are believed to have occupied all 92 positions based on their history of playing across all four divisions of the English Football League system. Brighton, for example, spent time in each division and fluctuated within those divisions, from nearly dropping out of the Football League entirely in the late 1990s to their current status in the Premier League.

However, without exact match-by-match data, it's difficult to prove definitively that they have held every single position, particularly mid-table positions in various leagues. So, while it is likely that Brighton has occupied a wide range of positions over the years, the claim of occupying all 92 positions is a broader historical assumption rather than a strictly documented fact for each specific position.

The same applies to other clubs like Coventry City, Wolverhampton Wanderers, and Carlisle United — while we know they have experienced highs and lows across all divisions, detailed records of each league position over time would be required to verify every spot.

Sake. I'm selling nvidia.

nickbrighton said:

The issue i see, is that especially since the advent of live televised matches, and becoming more frequent the closer to the present day, the number of matches each team has played at any given time can vary enormously, add in postponements, and other reasons, at which point do you take the position as being correct. To actually said to have occupied a particular place, surely it needs to be done when all teams have played the same number of games

Click to expand...

No, it doesn't. There are many times during a season when some clubs have played more than others, due to postponements, or, in the old days, cup replays.

Lenny Rider said:

Were we not predominantly in 92nd position for the majority of the 96/97 season, but finished in 91st place?

Click to expand...

Of course we were. Someone's talking twaddle.

The question was never about positions we've finished the season in, just positions we have occupied at some point.

Gotsmanov said:

Update: it's all BS. See below. An LLM can't easily solve this as it's based on nearest data points and assumptions. As a previous poster said you just need all the data, and some python.

Please can you list the date that Brighton occupied each of the 92 positions?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
While it would be fascinating to provide a full list of dates for every position Brighton & Hove Albion has occupied, this is extremely difficult because detailed historical league tables for every single matchday over the course of their entire history are not readily available, especially for lower league seasons. Furthermore, the fluctuation of league positions happens frequently during the course of a season, so teams can occupy several positions within just a few months.

However, I can provide a general outline of Brighton's journey through the 92 league positions:

General Milestones in Brighton's History:
Lowest Position (92nd): In the 1996-97 season, Brighton finished 91st in the Football League (24th in the old Division Three). It was during this season they came close to dropping out of the league entirely, needing a last-minute draw on the final day to avoid relegation to the non-league.

Top of the Premier League (1st position): While Brighton have reached the Premier League in recent seasons, they have not occupied the 1st position in the top division during their current stay. However, they have held positions in the top half of the Premier League.

Rise Through the Divisions: After the near collapse in the 1990s, Brighton began a long ascent, winning promotion to higher leagues. They returned to the Championship in the 2010-11 season and eventually secured promotion to the Premier League in the 2016-17 season.

Brighton's Historical League Progression:
1920: Brighton joined the Football League in Division Three South.
1958: The club reached the Second Division (equivalent to today’s Championship).
1983: Brighton reached the top flight (then the First Division) and finished 13th.
1996-97: Brighton dropped to near the bottom of the Football League pyramid, flirting with relegation to non-league.
2017-present: Brighton secured promotion to the Premier League in 2017 and has consistently played in the top division since.
It would be near impossible to track down the exact dates for every single position Brighton has held across the entire 92 spots in the Football League due to the fluctuating nature of league tables and the frequency of matches across decades.

You said:
If you are unable to provide the date for each, then how can you be certain that Brighton did indeed occupy each of the 92 positions?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
You raise an excellent point. The claim that Brighton & Hove Albion has occupied all 92 positions in the Football League is based on general historical analysis rather than a precise match-by-match tracking of their standings.

Clubs like Brighton are believed to have occupied all 92 positions based on their history of playing across all four divisions of the English Football League system. Brighton, for example, spent time in each division and fluctuated within those divisions, from nearly dropping out of the Football League entirely in the late 1990s to their current status in the Premier League.

However, without exact match-by-match data, it's difficult to prove definitively that they have held every single position, particularly mid-table positions in various leagues. So, while it is likely that Brighton has occupied a wide range of positions over the years, the claim of occupying all 92 positions is a broader historical assumption rather than a strictly documented fact for each specific position.

The same applies to other clubs like Coventry City, Wolverhampton Wanderers, and Carlisle United — while we know they have experienced highs and lows across all divisions, detailed records of each league position over time would be required to verify every spot.

Sake. I'm selling nvidia.

Click to expand...

11 vs 11 has it via their table generator. Of course over the history of football that is a lot of data. Even if you narrow it down to start from the creation of Div 3 North and South, or to the split to create 4 divisions in 1958 it’s still, at the very least, almost 70 years of tables to look through.

Mustafa II said:

I would say that due to the sheer amount of positions available

Click to expand...

92?

Triggaaar said:

92?

Click to expand...

Yes.

The fact there are 92 possible positions makes this extremely improbable.