mona
The Glory Game
It sounds as if he is on his way. I guess Gus wants a full back who is more comfortable on the ball. He is a real pro and has always given his all for the club.
Got something to say or just want fewer pesky ads? Join us... 😊
Thank you Andrew Whing
- Thread starter mona
- Start date
CliveWalkerWingWizard
Well-known member
If he goes it is a strange decision - there is no competition for RB and not a lot of cover
Surely he won't go before Villa... Poyet MUST know what it means to him... I know we can't sacrifice football results for niceities such as playing at Villa Park, but we still need cover, Whing has been an integral part of our tema last season and we prolly need him because i cannot take another half season of Hoyte...
What makes you say that?
The Wizard
Well-known member
- Jul 2, 2009
- 18,398
What. The. f***?
No room for that sentimental stuff - if he is going the Villa game will be neither here nor there for Gus
Tom Hark Preston Park
Will Post For Cash
- Jul 6, 2003
- 71,886
Very odd. Sometimes it's patently obvious that the fans know more than the manager. The fans knew more about Dicker's worth than Slade did. The fans know more about Whing's worth than Poyet appears to. Only defender while Jimmy Mac was out that fought tooth and nail for the colours. Patently stupid if he's let go.
severnside gull
Well-known member
murraymints4brighton
Well-known member
I agree. I rate him higher than Hoyte and without seeing Calderon play I can't compare the two yet an experienced RB in this division sounds better than a former Spain division two player who hasn't been at a club for 6 months.
Whing played against Southampton and then Wycombe, we won both of those games conceding 1 goal. The defense seemed very sturdy with him there. I think what Poyet has based his preference to Hoyte on is the fact at both those games win gave away a penalty.
dougdeep
New member
He's going nowhere, just you see.
I agree with the sntiment about many fans and managers but its a game of opinion. I know Whing tries hard, and did well at the end of last years dreadful season. Also agree about Slade / Diker but Im with Poyet. Whing's ball control and general footballing abilit is well short to play in a footballing side. Kick, rush and run around side is for Whing, I think Poyet expects more from his players, and football as moved on if you are going to be winners. But its a game of opinions as they say
Tom Hark Preston Park
Will Post For Cash
- Jul 6, 2003
- 71,886
and you do what exactly for a living................?
What that got to do with anything? The cognoscenti are NEVER wrong about an Albion player
Simon Morgan
New member
Can't understand for the life of me how Hoyte has got in ahead of Whing. Whing is better on every count for me and I would be very disappointed if he left.
murraymints4brighton
Well-known member
Did Woody phone you about Villa?
D
Deleted member 2719
Guest
Totally agree big mistake if he goes, i wish the manager would listen to the majority of fans/NSC as they have seen these player over a far longer period and are not biased about there personalities in anyway.
Even if he ain't first choice he would be superb cover.
He did give a hell of a lot to the club when few other players seem to bother and has always seemed to be totally professional. But, equally he did have limitations.
If he is leaving I really do hope that Poyet can give him some time on the pitch as Villa Park as a thank you. To make him one of the subs at Villa is no skin off anyone's nose. If circumstances allow he should at the very least get a few minutes.
If he is leaving I really do hope that Poyet can give him some time on the pitch as Villa Park as a thank you. To make him one of the subs at Villa is no skin off anyone's nose. If circumstances allow he should at the very least get a few minutes.
I agree, but GP clearly sees some real strength in Hoyte.
