Although Crofts was good yesterday, I'd say Gary Dicker.
He is a class above us, and leads by example. I think Gus will buy a player that plays like himself, meaning one of the 2 midfielders will get dropped. Dicker alongside a goalscoring midfielder would be amazing.
dicker probably, and he`s not on the list, but here`s a thing, i actually dont think the fans can pick a captain entirely, as you need to know what theyre like off the field as well as on, with the way they speak and interact with the players and staff, whether they command enough respect etc, something you cant tell unless youre in the coaching squad. We havent got a massively obvious choice like a cullip, horton or foster type player, they do seem overall to be a little bit much of a muchness. From afar though, id say Dicker.
If there's one thing where fans opinion should count for nothing it would be for picking captain. We're all going on what we've seen on the pitch/caught glimpses of what players are like through interveiws - you need a lot more than infomation like that to decide who the captain should be!
I'm with BG on this. I don't think anyone currently at the club will be the choice for captain after January. However, I think it's an experienced CB and/or commanding midfielder that will be brought in and take over the captaincy.