Pecking order @ CB

[Shropshire Seagull]

Given the various threads knocking about on Tank, McShane, El-Abd, Hinsh, et al . Assuming all were fit and available for selection (in a four across the back formation - RB,CB,CB,LB) - what would be your pecking order?

I'd pick Hinsh & McShane with El-Abd on the bench.

Tank & Elphick for the reserves I'm afraid.

 

[Schrödinger's Toad]

On their own merits:

McShane
Hinshelwood
Butters
El Abd
Elphick

Although you'd need a bigger defender - Hinsh & McShane are a bit of a small pairing.

 

[fatboy]

McShane
Hinshelwood
El-Abd
Butters
Lynch
Elphick

 

[Da Man Clay]

RB Reid
RCB El Abd
LCB McShane
LB Mayo

 

[sir danny cullip]

Mc Shane would be number one choice and then its a tough one between hinsh and el abd. If hinsh was producing as well as he did before he got injured then it would have to be him with el abd close behind.

 

[king Wombat]

hinshlewood hasn't played this season.

he's got to be at the bottom of the pecking order.

 

[Ringer]

Steady on people or you might get Tank throwing a hissy fit at you all!!

 

[London Irish]

hinshlewood hasn't played this season.

he's got to be at the bottom of the pecking order.

Fraid so. With a bad injury like that, you have to prove youself all over again.

 

[Strike]

McShane
Hinshelwood
Butters
El Abd
Mayo

 

[El Presidente]

I think the Tank is needed to win the high balls as otherwise we are lacking in that area, and then McShane until Christmas and Hinsh when he is fit

 

[Ringer]

McShane until Christmas?

Has he made a Lazarus-style return?

 

[Race]

Mcshane
el abd-hinsh
g.elphick
c.breach
t.elphick
j.lynch
m.stuart
ken the kit man
tank

 

[NMH]

Nah, ken has to be higher than THAT

 

[Race]

he's carrying an injury

 

[NMH]

Still, even injured would probably have scored a COUPLE for us today

 

[Yorkie]

Mcshane
el abd-hinsh
g.elphick
c.breach
t.elphick
j.lynch
m.stuart
ken the kit man
tank

 

[Kinky Gerbil]

Mcshane
el abd-hinsh
g.elphick
c.breach
t.elphick
j.lynch
m.stuart
ken the kit man
tank

You forgot my hamster Geek, just above ken

 

[Gully]

I have a feral cat living in my garden, reckon he could give your hamster a run for his money!!! (In fact I would fancy his chances in a fight with Charlie/Adam)

 

[Silent Bob]

RB: Reid
LB: DODD
CBs: Butters and McShane

 

[Stumpy Tim]

Tank is the only left-footed CB we have. He's first on the teamsheet at the moment