McShane - do we need him

[Barnet Seagull]

Whilst undoubtedly a class act, given the emergence of Lynch and El Abd this season should McShane be snapped up?

 

[Easy 10]

We need him like my bum needs a hole.

 

[Uncle Buck]

Yes, as he will add something to the squad and also you are almost certainly going to make a profit on that sort of player.

 

[blockhseagull]

If the price is right yes.... but need strengthening all round so wouldn't blow all we have on him

 

[sir danny cullip]

We need him like my bum needs a hole.

Couldnt have put it better myself He wont want to come back here though, probably end up somewhere like sheff utd or leeds.

 

[Loft23]

McShane has been inspirational for us so the answer would have to be yes.

 

[Superseagull]

I think centre back is the one part of the squad where we actually have a bit of depth, and where we can easily get loan cover if needed. It would be nice to get him, but there are more important signings to be made in the close season.

1. New left back if Lynch is sold
2. New central midfielder
3. New creative midfielder that was never replaced when Currie was sold.
4. New forward or two if GNW does not sign.

 

[Scotty Mac]

yes - he is probably the leading candidate for player of the season, so there is no doubt you need someone like him

 

[Les Biehn]

Would love to sign him but if we don't its not the end of the world. Quite looking forward to Hinsh and El-Abd at the back next year.

 

[Turkey]

I'd love to sign him but it's not going to happen. He wants to prove himself at United and if not he'll go to a better club than us.

 

[Silent Bob]

Would love to sign him but if we don't its not the end of the world. Quite looking forward to Hinsh and El-Abd at the back next year.

The lack of height in that partnership worries me. Of course signing McShane doesn't really solve that problem.

 

[Les Biehn]

The lack of height in that partnership worries me. Of course signing McShane doesn't really solve that problem.

I would say that Hinsh and El-Abd are both pretty good in the air, I rarely see El-Abd lose any headers.

 

[London Irish]

I'd love to sign him but it's not going to happen. He wants to prove himself at United and if not he'll go to a better club than us.

Yes. He's a foregone conclusion - much more interest centring around GNW I feel.

 

[Uncle Buck]

Yes. He's a foregone conclusion - much more interest centring around GNW I feel.

I think that is probably true, but you never know with these things.

Regarding Noel-Williams, he has made a difference, but are his knees going to be an issue, especially when it comes to a full time deal?

 

[jonny.rainbow]

Nope, we need him like a Metro needs leather seat covers.

 

[1066gull]

Yes we need him.

Both commercially for the club and on the pitch.

 

[NewtownRoad]

Yes we need him, he is our best player. Also think he could do a job in midfield.

 

[SJ's Love Monkey]

Brighton would love to keep him but it isnt going to happen

 

[Uncle Buck]

Brighton would love to keep him but it isnt going to happen

Can we have Tommy Black?

 

[jonny.rainbow]

Brighton would love to keep him but it isnt going to happen

I'd rather sign Emmerson Boyce. He's a real Albion legend.