It is going to be hard to compare with Potter seemingly somewhat workshy at the moment.
Maybe he is waiting for England, but that won't be comparing apples and apples.
So you are not really answering the question as to if you would be okay with him joining? More telling others why they are wrong to not want him here.
To do this though you have to ignore the differences between the two situations you are conflating.
To be fair you have done this effectively...
Come on Poskett stop flirting aroh d your half baked point on this thread, it has gone on too long.
Be brave, make your point and stand by it. Currently you are looking a little uncertain, almost as though you realise you are on somewhat shaky ground.
Why would you be happy to have him here?